| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 2026 SLG 5502 = 2026 SLD 5502 |
Federal Constitution Court of Pakistan
CPLA No. 302-P of 2023 [against the impugned judgment dated 15.03.2023 passed by the Peshawar High Court, Mingora Bench (Dar-ul-Qaza) Swat in W.P.No.17M of 2023]
Presented By: Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan, Chief Justice Justice Ali Baqar Najafi
Mr. Shah Faisal Ilyas, Addl. AG KPK Mr. Zahir Shah Inspector (L)
CPLA No. 302-P of 2023 [against the impugned judgment dated 15.03.2023 passed by the Peshawar High Court, Mingora Bench (Dar-ul-Qaza) Swat in W.P.No.17M of 2023]
Presented By: Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan, Chief Justice Justice Ali Baqar Najafi
Mr. Shah Faisal Ilyas, Addl. AG KPK Mr. Zahir Shah Inspector (L)
Provincial Police Officer KPK Peshawar …. Petitioner (s)
VERSUS
Hanifullah …. Respondent (s)
Law: Pakistan Penal Code, 1860
Section: 285, 286
Law: Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898
Section: 243
Law: Constitution of Pakistan, 1973
Section: 10-A
Law: Police Rules, 1934
Section: 12.14
Summary The respondent applied for the post of constable but was excluded due to a prior conviction under sections 285/286 PPC, registered through FIR No. 269 dated 22.04.2018. He was fined only Rs. 500 after admitting the accusation before the Magistrate. The Peshawar High Court, Mingora Bench, allowed his writ petition and directed the petitioner to consider him for the constable post. The department challenged that order, but the Court refused leave to appeal and upheld the High Court’s direction. Core Points The respondent was convicted under sections 285/286 PPC for negligent conduct relating to fire, combustible matter, or explosive substances. His punishment was only a Rs. 500 fine, imposed on the basis of a confessional statement. The Court treated this as a minor penalty for a minor, non-heinous offence and not an offence involving moral turpitude. A trivial or less harmful offence should not produce a severe, lifelong consequence such as permanent exclusion from government service. The Court emphasized that punishment must be proportionate to the offence and must not damage a person’s entire future. The respondent was not shown to be a habitual offender, and he had not concealed the conviction. The Court held that a confession may reflect repentance and an effort to avoid prolonged litigation, warranting reasonable leniency. A mere FIR, without indictment or conviction, remains only an allegation; however, in this case there was an actual minor conviction. Police recruitment rules require good character, but the Court held that this minor conviction did not justify a permanent bar to induction. The petition for leave to appeal was dismissed as meritless, meaning the High Court’s direction to consider the respondent for the constable post stands. Law and Sections Law / Provision Subject Relevance to the Case Section 285, Pakistan Penal Code Negligent conduct with respect to fire or combustible matter Covers rash or negligent acts involving fire or combustible material that endanger life or may cause hurt; punishable with up to six months’ imprisonment, a fine up to Rs. 3,000, or both. Section 286, Pakistan Penal Code Negligent…