| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 2026 SLG 5492 = 2026 SLD 5492 = 2026 FCC |
Federal Constitution Court of Pakistan
C.P.L.A No.1333 of 2025 [against the impugned judgment dated 13.03.2025, passed by the Lahore High Court, Multan Bench in Writ Petition No.11052 of 2024]
Presented By: Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan, Chief Justice Justice Ali Baqar Najafi
Mr. Waseem Mumtaz Malik, Addl.AG Mr. Abdul Waheed Zafar, LA Mr. Umair Shahid, LA
C.P.L.A No.1333 of 2025 [against the impugned judgment dated 13.03.2025, passed by the Lahore High Court, Multan Bench in Writ Petition No.11052 of 2024]
Presented By: Justice Amin-ud-Din Khan, Chief Justice Justice Ali Baqar Najafi
Mr. Waseem Mumtaz Malik, Addl.AG Mr. Abdul Waheed Zafar, LA Mr. Umair Shahid, LA
Chairperson TEVTA ...petitioner
VERSUS
Shahid Saleem & others ...Respondent
Law: Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, 1973
Section: 185(3),175F(1)(c)
Law: Punjab Employees Efficiency, Discipline and Accountability Act, 2006
Section: 4(1)(a)(iii),4(1)(b)(ii),4(1)(b)(v),10,10(6),11,12,13(6),16(2)(d)
Summary The Federal Constitutional Court allowed the department’s petition and set aside the Lahore High Court, Multan Bench judgment that had restricted the competent authority from imposing a punishment harsher than the earlier penalty. The Court held that, after a lawful de novo inquiry under the Punjab Employees Efficiency, Discipline and Accountability Act, 2006 (PEEDA), the competent authority could reconsider both guilt and proportionate punishment; it was not bound by the earlier lenient penalty where the fresh inquiry produced findings and material supporting a major penalty. Core points Shahid Saleem, respondent No. 1, was appointed as Assistant/Head Clerk Apprenticeship Officer (Additional Charge) at the Regional Directorate of Apprenticeship Training, Multan. Disciplinary proceedings were initiated against him under PEEDA, 2006 on allegations of non-accomplishment of official assignments, improper handing over of apprenticeship certificates, tampering with original certificates, and forwarding fake verification letters bearing forged details and signatures of the Deputy Director. The first Inquiry Officer found him guilty and recommended removal from service under section 4(1)(b)(v) of PEEDA. The competent authority, Director (AT), took a lenient view and instead imposed reduction to the lower post of Computer Operator (PS-15) for three years under section 4(1)(b)(ii), through order dated 31.07.2023. The Director General (Ops-II) set aside that penalty on 12.12.2023 and remanded the matter for a de novo inquiry under section 16(2)(d) of PEEDA. A fresh inquiry was conducted by another Inquiry Officer under sections 10, 11 and 12 of PEEDA; the report dated 25.04.2024 found the respondent guilty on all three charges and recommended removal from service. The competent authority accepted the recommendation and imposed removal from service under section 4(1)(b)(v), along with a fine of one month’s basic pay under section 4(1)(a)(iii), through order dated 28.06.2024. The appellate authority upheld the penalty on 28.08.2024. The respondent challenged both orders before the Lahore High Court, which allowed his writ petition on 13.03.2025. The…