| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 2026 SLG 5491 = 2026 SLD 5491 |
Federal Constitution Court of Pakistan
C.A. Nos.537 & 538 OF 2021, C.M.A.108-P/2021 AND C.P.L.A.6615/2021 (Against judgment dated 04.12.2020, passed by the Peshawar High Court, Peshawar in W.P.No.7461-P/2019)
Presented By: Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi Justice Aamer Farooq
Mr. Shah Faisal Ilyas, Addl. A.G, KPK a/w Safir Ullah, A.D (Audit), Mukhtiar Alam, ADEO (Litigation) (in C.A. No.538/2021)
C.A. Nos.537 & 538 OF 2021, C.M.A.108-P/2021 AND C.P.L.A.6615/2021 (Against judgment dated 04.12.2020, passed by the Peshawar High Court, Peshawar in W.P.No.7461-P/2019)
Presented By: Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi Justice Aamer Farooq
Mr. Shah Faisal Ilyas, Addl. A.G, KPK a/w Safir Ullah, A.D (Audit), Mukhtiar Alam, ADEO (Litigation) (in C.A. No.538/2021)
Chairman, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Text Book Board, Peshawar and another [in C.A. No.537/2021] Provincial Govt. of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa through Chief Secretary, Govt. of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Peshawar and others [in C.A. No.538/2021 & C.M.A.108-P/2021]
VERSUS
Umar Farooq and others [in C.P.L.A.6615/2021] ...Petitioner Versus Musadiq Ali Bangash and others …Respondent(s) (in all cases)
Law: Constitution of Pakistan 1973
Section: 185(3),199,175F(1)(c) ,175F(2)
Summary The Federal Constitutional Court allowed the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Textbook Board's appeal and set aside the Peshawar High Court judgment that had included Musadiq Ali Bangash in the seniority list of Assistants. The Court held that the earlier judgment had only granted him upgradation from BS-11 to BS-14; it did not absorb him into the Assistant cadre or confer seniority in that cadre. Since Assistants and Storekeepers were separate cadres, the Board lawfully maintained separate seniority lists. Core points Musadiq Ali Bangash was appointed as Assistant/Storekeeper (BS-11) by the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Textbook Board pursuant to an advertisement dated 21.05.2006; his initial three-year contractual appointment was regularised on 07.05.2009. Through notification dated 28.07.2007, the Provincial Government upgraded the post of Assistant from BS-11 to BS-14. The private respondent filed Writ Petition No. 2481-P/2013 seeking the benefit of that upgradation, alleging that other Assistants had received it while he had been denied the same benefit. On 19.02.2014, the Peshawar High Court granted him the benefit of the 28.07.2007 notification but expressly left the determination of his exact seniority to the respondents in accordance with law. In compliance, the Board upgraded him and initially included his name in a provisional seniority list of Assistants through order dated 29.09.2014. A departmental committee later concluded that Assistant and Storekeeper were separate cadres; the private respondent had been appointed as a Storekeeper and was therefore not entitled to inclusion in the Assistants' seniority list. The Board approved the committee's recommendation on 29.04.2015 and, through orders dated 19.05.2015 and 09.06.2015, maintained separate seniority lists for Assistants and Storekeepers, placing the private respondent in the Storekeepers' list. The private respondent's contempt petition alleging non-compliance with the earlier judgment was dismissed on 15.05.2019, with the High Court holding that the Board had implemented the judgment in letter and spirit. His departmental appeal was also dismissed by the Board on 07.02.2020. He then…