| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 2026 SLG 5478 = 2026 SLD 5478 = 2026 LHC 8839 |
Lahore High Court
W.P. No.29489 of 2026
Presented By: Muzamil Akhtar Shabir Judge
Date of hearing: 12.11.2026 Petitioner by: M/s. Ch. Mahmood-ur-Rehman, Kashif Bhatti, Mazhar Mahmood Bhatti, Ch. Abdul Razzaq and Kashif Ali Rana, Advocates for the petitioner. In attendance: Mr. Qamar Zaman Qureshi and Barrister Hassan Khalid Ranjha, Additional Advocates General, Punjab Mr. Qamar Hanif Ramay, Assistant Attorney General for Pakistan. M/s Malik Muhammad Altaf, Kashif Hussain, Shehryar Farhan Beg, Muhammad Dilbar Ghauri, Mian Qaisar Mahmood, Subhan Ali, Mazhar Hussain Tahir, Malik Khalid Tanveer, Abdul Manan Sipra, Rana Athar Raza Khan, Fayyaz Sandhu, Barrister Muhammad Sohail Babar Khan, Barrister Saeed Hussain Nagra, Sh. Faisal Sikandar Iqbal, Muhammad Shahid Malik, Malik Ali Raza Khokhar, Muhammad Shehzad Malik, Sarmad Ahmad Ghani, Mahar Salman Qutab, Syed Qaiser Gillani, Faisal Anwar Minhas, Ijaz Ahmad, Muhammad Naeem Mazhar, Ahmad Kamal Khan, Ch. Imtiazullah Warraich, Ch. Muhammad Naseer, Barrister Rana Khizar Hayat, Barrister Karim Ullah Sraw, Muhammad Waleed Waheed Chaudhry, Asif Raza Rasheed, Barrister Shahid Masood Khan, Syed Imran Ehsan, Muhammad Ali Butt, Zohaib Hassan Joya. Abdullah Haroon, Muhammad Saeed Bin Noman, Dr. Muhammad Azeem Raja, Syed Ali Allow-u-Din, Umair Yasin Khan, Muhammad Afzal, Mateen ul Haq Ch., M. Haris Jutt, Shafique Ahmad Bhutta, Zahid Saeed, Omer Riaz Chaudhary, Adeel Hassan, Kamran Ahmad, Hafiz Naeem ur Rehman, Barrister Hassan Safdar Khan, Arslan Aamir Tarar, Syed Muhammad Haider Kazmi, Syed Muhammad Nazim Abbas, Haider Zaman Khan, Saeed A. Sheikh, Jehangir Hassan Dogar, Ghulam Murtaza Chaudhry, Zeeshan Ahmad Ali Ranjha, Asad Hayat Bhoon, Sardar Farrukh Mushtaq, Ashiq Ali Rana, Ms. Asifa Ahmad, Ms. Humera Bashir, Ms. Isra Irshad, Ms. Musarrat Rehman, Ms. Maryam Khan Khosa, Ms. Zubera Bashir Chaudhry, and Ms. Moniba Nadeem, Advocates. Muhammad Abid, Civil Judge/Research Officer, Lahore, High Court, Lahore.
W.P. No.29489 of 2026
Presented By: Muzamil Akhtar Shabir Judge
Date of hearing: 12.11.2026 Petitioner by: M/s. Ch. Mahmood-ur-Rehman, Kashif Bhatti, Mazhar Mahmood Bhatti, Ch. Abdul Razzaq and Kashif Ali Rana, Advocates for the petitioner. In attendance: Mr. Qamar Zaman Qureshi and Barrister Hassan Khalid Ranjha, Additional Advocates General, Punjab Mr. Qamar Hanif Ramay, Assistant Attorney General for Pakistan. M/s Malik Muhammad Altaf, Kashif Hussain, Shehryar Farhan Beg, Muhammad Dilbar Ghauri, Mian Qaisar Mahmood, Subhan Ali, Mazhar Hussain Tahir, Malik Khalid Tanveer, Abdul Manan Sipra, Rana Athar Raza Khan, Fayyaz Sandhu, Barrister Muhammad Sohail Babar Khan, Barrister Saeed Hussain Nagra, Sh. Faisal Sikandar Iqbal, Muhammad Shahid Malik, Malik Ali Raza Khokhar, Muhammad Shehzad Malik, Sarmad Ahmad Ghani, Mahar Salman Qutab, Syed Qaiser Gillani, Faisal Anwar Minhas, Ijaz Ahmad, Muhammad Naeem Mazhar, Ahmad Kamal Khan, Ch. Imtiazullah Warraich, Ch. Muhammad Naseer, Barrister Rana Khizar Hayat, Barrister Karim Ullah Sraw, Muhammad Waleed Waheed Chaudhry, Asif Raza Rasheed, Barrister Shahid Masood Khan, Syed Imran Ehsan, Muhammad Ali Butt, Zohaib Hassan Joya. Abdullah Haroon, Muhammad Saeed Bin Noman, Dr. Muhammad Azeem Raja, Syed Ali Allow-u-Din, Umair Yasin Khan, Muhammad Afzal, Mateen ul Haq Ch., M. Haris Jutt, Shafique Ahmad Bhutta, Zahid Saeed, Omer Riaz Chaudhary, Adeel Hassan, Kamran Ahmad, Hafiz Naeem ur Rehman, Barrister Hassan Safdar Khan, Arslan Aamir Tarar, Syed Muhammad Haider Kazmi, Syed Muhammad Nazim Abbas, Haider Zaman Khan, Saeed A. Sheikh, Jehangir Hassan Dogar, Ghulam Murtaza Chaudhry, Zeeshan Ahmad Ali Ranjha, Asad Hayat Bhoon, Sardar Farrukh Mushtaq, Ashiq Ali Rana, Ms. Asifa Ahmad, Ms. Humera Bashir, Ms. Isra Irshad, Ms. Musarrat Rehman, Ms. Maryam Khan Khosa, Ms. Zubera Bashir Chaudhry, and Ms. Moniba Nadeem, Advocates. Muhammad Abid, Civil Judge/Research Officer, Lahore, High Court, Lahore.
Mst. Musarrat Muhammad Din
VERSUS
Safdar Ali, etc.
Law: Contract Act, 1872
Section: 25
The loss of immovable property is always considered irreparable loss and injury especially when the transfer of property is stated to be without consideration and based on fraud as agreement without consideration is void and fraud vitiates the most solemn of proceedings, hence plaintiff, who is stated to be of unsound mind, was entitled to interim relief for protection of his property.The petitioner challenged the orders of the two lower courts granting a temporary injunction in favour of Respondent No.1, Safdar Ali, who claimed ownership of the suit property and alleged that the relinquishment deed, gift deed and relevant mutations were obtained through fraud, misrepresentation and collusion. He further claimed to be a person of unsound mind and incapable of understanding legal transactions. The trial court, after conducting an inquiry under Order XXXII Rule 15 CPC, found prima facie that he was unable to understand his personal interests and allowed the temporary injunction restraining further alienation of the property. The High Court held that Respondent No.1 had established a prima facie case, balance of convenience and likelihood of irreparable loss, as the validity of the property transactions, his mental capacity, free consent and consideration were yet to be determined through evidence. The Court observed that fraud vitiates legal proceedings and transfer of the property could cause multiplicity of litigation. Consequently, finding no illegality or jurisdictional defect in the orders of the lower courts, the constitutional petition was dismissed, while directing that the trial court decide the main suit independently on its merits after recording evidence. JUDGMENT SHEET MUZAMIL AKHTAR SHABIR, J. The petitioner and respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are sister and brothers inter se. The petitioner, Mst. Musarrat Muhammad Din (‘Petitioner’), who was defendant No.2 before the trial court, through this constitution petition filed under Article 199 of the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973, has called in question order dated 27.05.2025 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Chiniot, whereby in a suit for declaration filed by the respondent…