| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 2009 SLG 49 2009 SLD 49 2009 PTD 1473 2010 PTCL 898 |
Writ Petition No. 8872 of 2008, decision dated: 15-05-2009, hearing DATE : 11th, 12th, 13th, 30th and 31st March, 2009, 1st 2nd, 3rd, 6th, 8th and 10-04-2009
Mian Ashiq Hussain, Ch. Anwar ul Haq-I, Mr. Muhammad Ajmal Khan, Mian Tabasam Bashir, Mr. Shahbaz Butt, Mian Mehmood Rashid, Mr. Siraj ud Din Khalid, Musthaq Ahmed Mughal, Muhammad Aslam Khan Dhakar, Sardar Muhammad Hussain Khan, Javed Iqbal Qazi, Akbar Ali Sheikh, Zafar Iqbal Chuhan, Shehzad Ahmed Durrani, Rana Muhammad Afzal, Sh Naveed Masud, Shafqat Mehmood Chuhan, Muhammad Naveed, Barrister Zargam Lakhser, Ch. Mumtaz ul Hasan, Muhammad Farooq Sheikh, Ijaz Ahmed Awan, Shahbaz. Siddique, Waqar Azeem, Shahid Mehmood Bhatti, Shahzada Mazhar, Javed Mazhar Dhoon, Ijaz ul Ahsan, Ustad Muhammad Iqbal, Muhammad Akram Shahid, Ch. Mumtaz ul Hasan, Qamar uz Zaman Akhtar Tarar, Rana Munir Hussain, Muhammad Akhtar Rana, Khalid Nawaz Ghuman, Malik Imran Nazir Awan, Kh. Saeed uz Zafar, Rana Muhammad Arshad Khan, Ijaz Ali Bhatti, Irtaza Ali Naqvi Muhammad Arif Yaqub Khan, Muhammad Jamil ur Rehman, Muhammad Waseem, Aamir Umar Khan, Zahid Farani Sheikh, Abdul Razaq Mirza, Asif Masud Khan, Ali Mansur Malik, Muhammad Nadeem, Umar Alvi, Abdul Qadoos Mughal, Ghulam Abbas Sandhu, Aamir Ali Khan, Agha Sarfraz, Muhammad Saqib Sheikh, Muhammad Hussain Chutia, Tariq Saleem Sheikh, Muhammad Aamir Malik and Muhammad Shahzad Shaukat for Petitioners. Muhammad Ilyas Khan, Senior Legal Advisor Income Tax, Shahid Jamil Khan, Jan Muhammad Chaudhri, Tahir Mehmood Khokhar and Fayyaz Sangera for
Respondents
INDUS JUTE MILLS LTD. through Chief Executive
VS
FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Secretary Finance, Islamabad and 3 others
Law:
Section: 47,52,169,234A,235,235(1),235(4)
(a) Income Tax Ordinance (XLIX of 2001)---S. 235---Constitution of Pakistan (1973), Art.199 & Fourth Schedule Federal Legislative List, Item 47---Constitutional petition---Vires of S.235, Income Tax Ordinance, 2001.--Three stages of imposition of tax i.e. declaration of liability; assessment and recovery---Said three stages need not necessarily occur in any particular order---Recovery of tax whether directly from the assessee or indirectly through collection from expenditure or deduction from receipts, as the case may be, did not amount to assessment of tax, nor created any liability to pay said amount---Advance tax was merely a provisional payment---Mode of recovery of tax was not the sole determining factor in ascertaining the subject-matter of tax---"Collection of tax" and "its levy or chargeability", distinguished---Mode of collection of tax through advance tax was valid and legal, challenge thereto on the grounds of being violative of fundamental rights/or beyond the legislative competence of the Parliament was rejected---Provision for collection of advance tax was within legislative competence of Parliament in view of Fourth Schedule Item 47 of Federal Legislative of the Constitution---Collection of advance tax on the amount of bills did not affect the essential subject-matter of tax which remained tax on income, however, in case of companies subject-matter of the tax remained the income of the assessee and not the electricity bill---Principles. Whiteny v. Inland Revenue Commissioners AIR 1926 AC 37; Elahi Cotton Mills Ltd. PLD 1997 SC 582; Call Tel and another v. Federation of Pakistan and others 2005 PTD 833 and Call Tel Pvt. Ltd. v. Federation of Pakistan 2004 PTD 3032 ref. (b) Income Tax Ordinance (XLIX of 2001)--- ----Ss. 235 & 169---Companies---Contention was that some companies may be entitled to final discharge under S.169, Income Tax Ordinance, 2001; hence, S.235 of the Ordinance could not be applied to them---Held, in case of presumptive tax regimes where there was a final, discharge of liability under S.169 of the Ordinance, said discharge was limited to the transaction or the income covered by such provision of the presumptive tax…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492