| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1952 SLG 177 1952 SLD 177 1952 PLD 489 |
Lahore High Court
Second Appeal No. 272 of 1950 decided on 7th June 1952, from the decree of Sheikh Bashir Ahmad, (District Judge, Mianwali) Ex-officio, Additional District Judge, Multan, dated the 26th May 1950 affirming that of Major Fazal-i-Haq, Senior Civil Judge, Mult
S. A. RAHMAN AND M.A. SOOFI, JJ
Muhammad Amin Khan for Appellant. B. Z. Kaikaus for
Respondent No. 8.
Second Appeal No. 272 of 1950 decided on 7th June 1952, from the decree of Sheikh Bashir Ahmad, (District Judge, Mianwali) Ex-officio, Additional District Judge, Multan, dated the 26th May 1950 affirming that of Major Fazal-i-Haq, Senior Civil Judge, Mult
S. A. RAHMAN AND M.A. SOOFI, JJ
Muhammad Amin Khan for Appellant. B. Z. Kaikaus for
Respondent No. 8.
MUHAMMAD AKRAM KHAN
VS
Mst. KANIZ FATIMA BIBI and others
Law:
Section:
(a) Punjab Pre-emption Act (I of 1913)-----------S. 28-Decree obtained by one pre-emptor, during pendency of suit of another in violation of provisions of S. 28, of no avail. Two pre-emptors instituted suits one after the other without each impleading his rival pre-emptor as party in case. One of them got a consent decree in his favour while the suit of the other was pending: Held, that decree thus obtained was of no avail as against the other pre-emptor whose suit was pending, and that the latter, in the circumstances, was entitled to a decree for the whole of the property sought to be pre-empted. (b) Pre-emption------ -----right of -May be defeated by a second sale in favour of pre-emptor with superior right, the latter obtaining the property in bona fide exercise of his right and for his own benefit-Lis pendens. It is a well-recognized principle of the Pre-emption Law that in order to defeat the plaintiff-pre-emptor, the second sale must be in favour of another pre-emptor with a superior right, in the bona fide exercise of that right, for his own benefit and not for the benefit of other persons. Where transfers were made to strangers while the suit of a pre-emptor was pending the transfers were hit by the rule of lis pendens. JUDGMENT RAHMAN, J.-This order will dispose of a regular second appeal arising out of a pre-emption suit brought by Muhammad Akram Khan to pre-empt the sale of a house effected by Muhammad Rab Nawaz Khan defendant No. 2 in favour of Mst. Kaniz Fatima defendant No. 1, by deed dated the 12th January 1945, which was registered on the 22nd January 1945, for an ostensible consideration of Rs. 2,600. It appears that Amir Baz Khan defendant No. 3, had also brought another preemption suit in respect of the same property, a little earlier than Muhammad Akram Khan. Amir Baz Khan obtained a consent decree in his favour on the 23rd January 1946. Two days later, i.e., on the 25th January 1946, Amir Baz Khan sold the house that he had obtained under the pre-emption decree; to Allah Ditta defendant No. 4 and Barkat Ali defendant No. 5, along with his own house on which his claim of preemption was founded. This sale-deed was registered on the 26th…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492