| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1952 SLG 158 1952 SLD 158 1952 PLD 376 |
Lahore High Court
Regular Second Appeal No. 180 of 1950 decided on 26th March, 1952, from the decree of the Court of Khan Inayat Ullah Khan, Additional District Judge, Lahore, dated the 11th February, 1950 affirming that of Chaudhri Muhammad Anwar, Subordinate judge, 1st C
MUHAMMAD KHURSHID ZAMAN AND M. R. KAYANI, JJ
Qazi Muhammad Ashraf, for Appellant. Sheikh Akbar Ali and Syed Muhammad Amin Indrabi, for
Respondent.
Regular Second Appeal No. 180 of 1950 decided on 26th March, 1952, from the decree of the Court of Khan Inayat Ullah Khan, Additional District Judge, Lahore, dated the 11th February, 1950 affirming that of Chaudhri Muhammad Anwar, Subordinate judge, 1st C
MUHAMMAD KHURSHID ZAMAN AND M. R. KAYANI, JJ
Qazi Muhammad Ashraf, for Appellant. Sheikh Akbar Ali and Syed Muhammad Amin Indrabi, for
Respondent.
PIR BAKHSH
VS
PIR BAHAUDDIN
Law:
Section:
Pre-emption Act (I of 1913)-----------S. 22 (1) (4) (5) (a)-Three pre-emptor-plaintiffs-Two of them entering into compromise and withdrawing their share of deposit-Third plaintiff ordered to make up deficiency of deposit occasioned by the withdrawal by a certain date but failing to do so-Whether plaint could be rejected-Whether withdrawal was competent: The necessary deposit under section 22 (1) of the Preemption Act was made by the three pre-emptor-plaintiffs before striking of issues and the case went up to the evidence stage when two of the plaintiffs entered into a compromise with the defendant and retired from the suit, withdrawing also their share of the deposit. The third plaintiff was ordered by the Court to make up-the deficiency in deposit by a certain Ate, which he failed to do. Held, that since, in the first instance, a proper deposit had been made in compliance with the order of the Court under subsection (1), there was no justification for rejecting the plaint under subsection (4). As for the question whether the suit could be dismissed as a whole, admittedly, the money was withdrawn by the two plaintiffs at a time when they were no longer plaintiffs and when the only plaintiff on the file was the third one and since it was not withdrawn by the latter, it cannot be said that the provision of subsection 5 (a) which rests on a withdrawal by the plaintiff only was infringed ; and if that was not infringed then the suit also could not be dismissed. If deposit is to be made, it should be required to be made before the settlement of issues. It would appear that no order made after that stage is binding on the plaintiff. There was consequently no provision for any deposit to be made at the stage when the trial Court required the third plaintiff to make the deposit and no provision whatsoever for any deficiency to be made up. The stage when the present plaintiff should have been required to make the deposit is long past and the suit can proceed even without any deposit having been required and made. Gobind v. Kishan Chand 52 P R 1891, ref. One is not sure that the Court acted properly in allowing the first two plaintiffs to withdraw their share of the…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492