| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1952 SLG 149 1952 SLD 149 1952 PLD 294 |
Lahore High Court
First Appeal No. 40 of 1949, decided on 18th March, 1952, from the decree of Chaudhri Tufail Ahmad, Civil Judge, 1st Class, Gujranwala, dated the 3rd January, 1949.
MUHAMMAD KHURSHID ZAMAN AND KAYANI, JJ
M. G. M. Din and Sheikh Nazir Ahmad, for Appellants. B. Z. Kaikaus, for
Respondents 1 to 5 and Muhammad Amin Khan, for
Respondents 6 and 7.
First Appeal No. 40 of 1949, decided on 18th March, 1952, from the decree of Chaudhri Tufail Ahmad, Civil Judge, 1st Class, Gujranwala, dated the 3rd January, 1949.
MUHAMMAD KHURSHID ZAMAN AND KAYANI, JJ
M. G. M. Din and Sheikh Nazir Ahmad, for Appellants. B. Z. Kaikaus, for
Respondents 1 to 5 and Muhammad Amin Khan, for
Respondents 6 and 7.
Mst. SARDAR BIBI and 2 others
VS
ABDUL LATIF and 7 others
Law:
Section:
(a) Custom (Punjab)------Ancestral property-Presumption as to ancestral nature of property found to be held in ancestral shares-Whether may relate also to Settlements subsequent to first-Presumption supported from probabilities-Settlement (1892-93), Gujranwala District. In 1892-93 the land in dispute was held by the descendants of the common ancestor in ancestral shares. As no earlier records of the District (Gujranwala) were available, the presumption that if at the time of the first settlement land is found to be held by the sons of the common ancestor in ancestral shares, the land must have been held by the common ancestor, was held to be applicable in view, also, of other probabilities. Such a probability attached in the present case to the record of 1892-93, though of a weaker nature, since no earlier records were available. This, together with the facts that the village was founded by a common ancestor, that since the formation of the tarafs the history of the village did not show any acquisitions, and that in the pedigree-table, although alienations had been shown against individual proprietors, there were no acquisitions, the only acquisition being that of a daughter by virtue of a gift from her father, created a strong probability that the property in suit was ancestral. Lakha Singh v. Gujjar Singh, A I R 1931 Lah. 704 ; Jiwan Singh v. Har Kaur, 41 P R 1914 ; Jhanda Singh v. Mst. Banto, A I R 1927 Lah. 477, ref. (b) Res-judicata------ ----Finding in earlier suit against one party -Earlier suit and appeal, however, decided in favour of such party on other grounds-Finding, though not res judicata in subsequent suit casts heavy burden on prove contrary. In the previous suit of the plaintiffs it was held that the property involved in that suit was ancestral, the suit having on the whole been decided in favour of the defendants and the appeal also having been decided in their favour on a short ground, they had no opportunity of contesting that finding, which could not therefore be regarded as res judicata. Held, that even though not res judicata, the finding cast a heavy burden on the other party to prove the contrary. Mst. Aziman v. Ibrahim Beg A I R…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492