| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1951 SLG 98 1951 SLD 98 1951 PLD 169 |
Lahore High Court
Letters Patent Appeal No. 22 of 1948, decided on 9th January, 1951.
MUHAMMAD MUNIR, C.J. AND MUHAMMAD SHARIF, J.
Yaqub Ali Khan, for Appellant. B. Z. Kaikaus, for
Respondents.
Letters Patent Appeal No. 22 of 1948, decided on 9th January, 1951.
MUHAMMAD MUNIR, C.J. AND MUHAMMAD SHARIF, J.
Yaqub Ali Khan, for Appellant. B. Z. Kaikaus, for
Respondents.
MUHAMMAD SARWAR
VS
FEROZ KHAN and anothers
Law:
Section:
(a) Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908)-----S. 100-Second Appeal -Question of fact-Whether physical possession passed to vendee in pre-emption suit-Lower Appellate Court's fending that possession had passed to vendee before certain date-But nowhere held that possession was physical-Some evidence on record not discussed-High Court van examine whole position de novo. There was no clear finding by the District Court that physical possession "over any part of the property in suit, was transferred on 1st March 1943. All that was found by the District Court was, that possession had passed to the vendee before the transaction was reported to the patwari on 8th March 1943. It was nowhere found that " physical possession " had actually been delivered by the vendor to the vendee before 8th of March 1943. The real question was whether " physical possession had been transferred over any part of the property forming the subject-matter of sale. There was, therefore, no finding of fact on the matter in issue, which would have precluded a further inquiry into the question of "physical possession" in second appeal. Some evidence on the record was not at all taken into consideration by the District judge. The so-called finding of fact by the learned District judge, was, therefore, vitiated and the learned judge in Chambers was perfectly within his right to examine the whole position de novo in the light of the evidence produced in the case. (b) Limitation Act (IX of 1908)----- --Art. 10-Afiplaes to case where sale -is by registered instrument-Physical Possession Not same as possession-Object of physical possession-To give notice to all concerned of transfer-Mere admission by vendor at time, of report to patwari or statement to Revenue Officer that vendor had surrendered possession to vendee does not bind pre-emptor- Waste land-Condition not changed-Some concrete and visible taking of Possession by vendee, such as ploughing land or fencing it round not proved-Time runs from date of registration or date of mutation-Punjab Pre-emption Act (I of 1913), S. 30. Article 10, Schedule I Limitation Act (1908) obviously applies to those cases where the sale is evidenced by a registered…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492