Case Details

Citation(s)
1951 SLG 29 1951 SLD 29 1951 PLD 338
Lahore High Court
Regular Second Appeal Case No. 227 of 1949, decided on 18th May, 1951 against the decree of P. R. B. May, Esqr., District Judge, Rawalpindi, dated the 21st May, 1949
MUHAMMAD, JAN, J
Vir Sen Sawhney, for Appellants. Dr. Khalif a Shuja-ud-Din, for
Respondents

ABDUL GHANI and 2 others

VS

PIR NAZIR AHMAD and another

Law:

Section:

Practice-Pleadings-Introducing obscure pleadings to take opposite party by surprise-Should not be allowed. The practice of introducing obscure pleadings, with a view to taking the adversary by surprise, is open to grave objection and is not unoften likely to lead to grave miscarriage of justice. A. I. R. 1938 P. C. 121, I. L. R. 33 Born. 35, A. I. R 1939 Cal. 513, A. I. R. 1941 Oudh 457 and A. I. R. 1940 Pat. 187 relied on. ORDER MUHAMMAD JAN, J.-Abdul Ghani, Muhammad Amin and Fazal Din, sons of Haji Alif Din, caste Maliar Rajput of Rawalpindi filed a suit on 20th March, 1946 for possession by pre­emption of 35 kanals and 19 marlas of land alienated by their father on 3rd April, 1945, in favour of Nazir Ahmad, Sajjada­nashin of Mohra Sharif, Tehsil Murree ; or, in the alternative, for a declaration that the alienation of resaid shall be void and ineffective on the plaintiff's rights after the death of their father Alif Din. It was stated in the plaint that the alienation purported to be a gift but, in fact, was a sale in consideration of Rs. 6,500. It was alleged to have been given the garb of a gift in order to dissuade the plaintiffs from challenging it, because it was ostensibly for a religious purpose, and in order to defeat the plaintiffs' right of pre-emption. The alienor and the alienee were alleged to have acted dishonestly in adopting this device. The plaintiffs claimed a preferential right of pre-emption in respect of the land which was said to be ancestral qua the plaintiffs who were governed by customary law. The alienation was alleged to be without legal necessity and without the consent of the plaintiffs. The suit was contested by the transferee, Nazir Ahmad Sajjadanashin, on the grounds that the alienation was in reality a gift and, therefore, not pre-emptible ; and that the plaintiffs were governed by Muhammadan Law according to which an owner can make a valid gift. The property was stated to be non-ancestral and it was added that even according to customary law property, ancestral or non-ancestral can be gifted for charitable religious purposes. Before framing issues, counsel for the parties were examined by the Court. The counsel for the…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492