Case Details

Citation(s)
1951 SLG 195 1951 SLD 195 (1951) 20 ITR 201
Bombay High Court

CHAGLA, C.J. TENDOLKAR, J.

Deprecated: str_replace(): Passing null to parameter #3 ($subject) of type array|string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 395

Keshrichand Bhanabhai

v.

Commissioner of Income Tax

Law:

Section:

Section 72 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [Corresponding to section 24(2) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922] - Losses - Carry forward and set off of business losses - Assessment year 1942-43 - Assessee, a registered firm, came into existence after partition of HUF recognised by ITO under section 25A of 1922 Act - HUF had suffered loss in previous assessment year while assessee firm made profit in relevant assessment year - Assessing Officer disallowed assessee's claim of setting off of loss of HUF against income of firm - Whether since Act recognizes as an assessee and as an independent unit, not only an individual, but a Hindu undivided family and a registered firm, registered firm is not same entity as a HUF - Held, yes - Whether mere fact that same coparceners who constituted HUF should choosed to carry on partnership business did not lead one to inference that under Act they constituted same entity and were same assessees - Held, yes - Whether, therefore, it was not competent to assessee-firm to claim set-off in respect of loss incurred by HUF which was altogether different assessee - Held, yes FACTS The assessee, a registered firm, came into existence after partition of a HUF recognised by the ITO under section 25A of the 1922 Act from 22-11-1940. The HUF had suffered loss in the assessment year 1941-42 while the assessee-firm made profit for the assessment year 1942-43. The assessee-firm claimed that it was entitled to set off the loss of the HUF against the income of the firm on ground that the assessee which sustained the loss in 1941-42 was the same assessee which made the profit in 1942-43 and, therefore, section 24(2) of the 1922 Act was applicable. The assessee's contention was not accepted by the ITO and set off was not allowed. The AAC confirmed the action of the ITO. The Tribunal also dismissed assessee's second appeal. On reference: HELD It is clear on the plain reading of section 24(2) of the 1922 Act that the assessee who sustains a loss and the assessee to whom the set-off is allowed must be the same. The Act recognizes as an assessee and as an independent unit, not only an individual, but a HUF and a registered firm, and, therefore, a…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492