Case Details

Citation(s)
1992 SLG 2093 1992 SLD 2093 1992 PLJ 179
Lahore High Court
Writ Petition No.7630 of 1991 (also 61 other writ petitions) dismissed on 24.11.1991. Dates of hearing: 1?-18, 23 and 24.11.1991.
ZLA MAHMOOD MLRZA, J
Ch. Mushtaq Ahmad Khan, Advocate for Petitioner. Mr. Farooq Bedar, Additional Advocate General, and Rana Muhammad Arshad, Additional Advocate General for
Respondents.

Mst. SHAGUFTA YOUNUS

VS

DIRECTOR OF EDUCATION ETC.--Respondents

Law: Constitution of Pakistan, 1973

Section: 199

(i) Constitution of Pakistan, 1973- —-Art.199 read with Article 212-Education employees-Transfer of Cancellation of transfer orders-Challenge to~Whether writ petitions are maintainable-Question of-It is fairly settled that in matters relating to terms and conditions of service, jurisdiction of all other courts including High Court, stands completely ousted under Article 212 of Constitution—Mere fact that these orders were issued on direction of Chief Minister, would not render them orders of a non-departmental authority-They would be appealable before service Tribunal-Held: Jurisdiction of High Court stands completely ousted by virtue of Article 212 of Constitution.          [Pp.l81,182183]A,BC PLJ 1990 SC 503, NLR 1981 Service 96 and PLJ 1989 Lahore 288 distinguished  (ii) Locus Poenitentia- —Education employees-Transfer of-Cancellation of transfer orders- Challenge to-Whether principle of locus poenitentia was not available to respondents to withdraw/cancel transfer orders-Question of~Petitioners had no vested right to be posted at any particular place-Under Section 9 of Punjab Civil Servants Act, 1972, a civil servant is liable to serve at any place in Province-Held: Impugned orders directing petitioners to report back to their previous places of posting, prima fade, do not appear to be open to any exception-Petitions dismissed.                          [P.183JDE JUDGMENT This judgment shall dispose of sixty-two writ petitions bearing (numbers) 7630-91, 7634-91, 7635-91, 7637-91, 7639-91, 7640-91, 7642-91, 7643-91, 7646-91, 7647-91, 7649-91, 8112-91, 8115-91, 8114-91, 8113-91, 8116-91, 8117-91, 8118-91, 8119-91, 8120-91, 8121-91, 8122-91, 8123-91, 8124-91, 8125-91, 8126-91, 8164-91, 8165-91, 8166-91, 8167-91, 8168-91, 8169-91, 8581-91, 8582-91, 8583-91, 8584-91, 8023-91, 8024-91, 8025-91, 8026-9^ 8163-91, 9051-91, 6909-91, 7575-91, 7430-91, 9251-91, 10023-91, 8250-91, 7843-91, 7786-91, 7722-91, 8130-91, 8160-91, 8241-91,8233-91, 8476-91, 9346-91, 9813-91, 7798-91, 7826-91, 7778-91 and 10201-91 all of which are directed against almost identical orders passed by…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492