Law:

Section:

Keywords: Copy, Grievance, Money, Chairman, Presentation, Costs, Endorsement, Custody, Order, Prevention, Goods, Period, Investigation, Receipt, Disposal, Expunction, Communication JUDGMENT JUSTICE (RTD) MUNAWAR ALI KHAN (CHAIRMAN).-By this appeal Mr. Muhammad Sadique, SIP Ghotki, District Sukkur has sought expunction of the adverse remarks awarded to him for the year 1987. As disclosed in the memo of appeal, Mr. Noor Ahmed Pechooho, DSP/PSDO Ghotki had initiated the said remarks as reporting officer. They pertained to the period from 13.7.1987 to 31.12.1987 during which the appellant had served as SHO Ghotki under the aforementioned reporting officer. The remarks were conveyed to the appellant through SSP, Sukkur vide IGP's letter No. 10550/S-1/88, dated 27.11.1988. On receipt of the adverse remarks on 13.12.1988, the appellant hastened to file appeal/representation to the IGP for expunction of the same. The said appeal was rejected vide IGP's letter dated 20.9.1990 addressed to the DIGP who vide his endorsement dated 24.9.1990, forwarded a copy thereof to SP/ACE, Sukkur for service on the appellant. He received the said communication on 8.10.1990, Accordingly this appeal was filed on 7.11.1990. 2. We heard the arguments of both the appellant learned counsel and the learned AAG. We also perused the documents relevant for disposal of the appeal. The adverse remarks sought to be expugned are stated as under: ((Table Start))13. 14. #tbs 15. 14. 16. the 17. Rating for morality. Controversial. Relation with (a) Public: ~ Bad. (b) (c) tbs (d) 15. Integrity: General Remarks. (e) the (f) Colleagues: - Bad. - Controversial. "He is neither a good officer nor a good subordinate. He is poor in prevention, detection and investigation of the heniou crimes. He is not trustworthy"((Table End)) While disputing the correctness of the above remark the learned counsel for the appellant bitterly attacked the reporting officer. According to him Mr. Noor Ahmed Pechooho, the then DSP Ghotki who was the author of the controversial ACR had personal bias against the appellant, as the latter had reported to the SSP, Sukkur verbally as well as in writing, that the said DSP had crossed all…

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492