Law:

Section:

(a) Civil service--- ----Annual Confidential Report---Adverse remarks, expunction of---Appellant working as Executive Engineer was conveyed adverse remarks relating to year 1983---Appellant's departmental representation for expunction of said remarks was rejected---Reporting Officers were not alone in making assessment of work of officer, it was reported as such by higher authority i.e. Chief Engineer countersigning authority---Arguments by appellant that no counseling had been given thus carried no weight---Two officers who reported against appellant during 1983 had been advising appellant to improve upon various aspects of hi: working---Contention of appellant that adverse remarks were not communicates to him within the time was also not tenable as adverse remarks communicated to appellant though late were as effective as communicated in time and could not have any effect of washing them off---Adverse remarks were not expunged 1987 P L C (C.S.) 434 ref. (b) Civil service--- ---- Annual Confidential Report---Evaluation and assessment of performance of civil servant to be made by reporting officer who is within his legal rights to award adverse remarks in one or more aspects of the conduct and work of civil servant being reported upon. JUDGMENT IMTIAZ RASOOL (MEMBER).---Appellant Ali Gohar Abro presently working as Executive Engineer in the Communication and Works Department of the Government of Sindh has filed this appeal seeking quashment of the adverse remarks conveyed to him by Section Officer E(1) on behalf of Secretary of the aforesaid Department under his letter dated 28-8-1986 relating to the calendar year 1983. ACR of the appellant for the year 1983 has been recorded in parts, by two reporting officers. The adverse remarks communicated to the appellant vide the said letter are reproduced hereunder: (a) Period from 1-1-1983 to 4-9-1983:-- (i) Ability to produce Constructive ideas: Below average (ii) Financial responsibility: Below average (iii) Relations with superiors: Below average (iv) Behaviour with public: Below average (b) Period from 10-9-1983 to 31-12-1983: (i) Intelligence: Below average (ii) Confidence and will power: Below average (iii)…

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492