| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1997 SLG 1022 1997 SLD 1022 1997 PLC 1142 |
Supreme Court of Pakistan
Civil Petition No.537-K of 1989, decision dated: 18-04-1996. (On appeal from the judgment dated 29-8-19.a8 passed by the Federal Service Tribunal, Government of Pakistan, Islamabad in Appeal No. 107(K) of 1984).
NAIMUDDIN AND ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON, JJ
Ch. A. Aziz, Advocate Supreme Court and A.A. Siddiqui, AdvocateonRecord for Petitioner. Nemo for
Respondent.
Civil Petition No.537-K of 1989, decision dated: 18-04-1996. (On appeal from the judgment dated 29-8-19.a8 passed by the Federal Service Tribunal, Government of Pakistan, Islamabad in Appeal No. 107(K) of 1984).
NAIMUDDIN AND ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON, JJ
Ch. A. Aziz, Advocate Supreme Court and A.A. Siddiqui, AdvocateonRecord for Petitioner. Nemo for
Respondent.
Dr. AZIZ BEGUM CHAUDHARY
VS
PAKISTAN through Secretary (Establishment Division)
Law:
Section:
Civil service-- Retirement from service on medical ground with retrospective effect-Validity of order of retirement, as also verdict of Central Medical Board and of Appellate Review Medical Board challengedService Tribunal declared the convening of Appellate Medical Board to be without lawful authority and decision of retirement being based on such opinion was also set asideService Tribunal deemed such verdict of Central Medical Board to be not final order for preferring appeal against the sameService Tribunal's finding relating to opinion of Central Medical Board challengedAfter Central Medical Board had given its opinion, Appellate Review Medical Board was constituted on appeal filed by civil servantAppellate Review Medical Board gave opinion that civil servant was not fit for retention in Government serviceAppellate Review Board's opinion was, however, declared invalid by Service Tribunal on the ground that said Board was not properly constitutedOpinion of Central Medical Board which had merged into subsequent opinion of Appellate Review Medical Board was also rendered invalid and, thus, did not hold the fieldApprehension expressed by civil servant that opinion of Central Medical Board would come in his way even if she was reinstated in service was misconceived and unwarranted for it could not be conceived that any relevant authority would, .still press into aid opinion of Central Medical Board against civil servant after her reinstatement in service. ORDER ABDUL HAFEEZ MEMON, J.Petitioner was selected for the Central Medical Services, Class II by the DirectorGeneral of Health, Government of Pakistan, Ministry of Health and Social Welfare, Karachi, and appointed as Resident Medical Officer, Jinnah Central Hospital by an order dated 1561990. Her service was terminated twice and after the orders of her termination were set aside as illegal by the High Court on 3101963 in Constitutional petition and by the Federal Services Tribunal on 1521982 in the appeal, she was ultimately reinstated in service and was finally posted at Haji Camp Dispensary, Karachi, on 2981982. She applied for leave for 14 days on medical grounds. She was, however, directed vide memo.…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492