Law:

Section:

Civil service--- ---- Adverse remarks ---Expunction---Adverse remarks/below average grading recorded in different parts under columns of A.C.R. of civil servant and duly communicated to him, had been sought by civil servant to be expunged---Civil servant had contended that Reporting Officer belonged to same discipline to which civil servant belonged and that he being Incharge of civil servant, was in better position to have judged his performance and conduct than the Countersigning Officer who belonged to different discipline, and was not so familiar as Reporting Officer, with the job and work of civil servant---Civil servant contended that assessment made by Reporting Officer was to prevail over that of Countersigning Officer, but unfortunately the Reporting Officer had also graded civil servant as "below average" in more than one columns---Assessment and remarks, recorded by Countersigning Officer, who was Director and local head of the Laboratories concerned and also had supervisory and administrative role, were real reflection on work and conduct of civil servant which he made by closely watching performance and work of civil servant---Opinion of Supervisory Officer under the Rules always prevailed over opinion of subordinate officer---Held, Countersigning Officer was justified in writing his assessment on work and performance of civil servant in his A.C.R. there being no inconsistency between his assessment and that of Reporting Officer so far as performance of work .and devotion to duty was concerned nor there was any element of bias and mala fide involved---Civil servant had failed to make out case for expunction of adverse remarks in circumstances. 1991 SCMR 2330 and Province of Punjab v. Sardar Noor Ilahi Khans Leghari 1992 SCMR 1427 ref. Appellant in person. Niaz Ahmed Khan, Standing Counsel for Respondents. Date of hearing: 17th May, 1995. JUDGMENT NOOR MUHAMMAD MAGSI (MEMBER).---Appellant Mr. Syed Afzal Ahmed Hydri was working as Research Officer at the relevant time in the DESTO Laboratories, when he was communicated certain adverse remarks recorded in his A.C.R. for the period January, 1993 to December, 1993, by the Countersigning Officer, Mr. S.…

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492