Case Details

Citation(s)
1950 SLG 63 1950 SLD 63 = 1950 PLD 108
Lahore High Court
Civil Revision Petition No. 120 of 1949, decided on 23rdJanuary, 1950 under section 25 of Small Cause Courts Act,for revision of judge, Small Cause Court, Lahore, dated 13thAugust, 1949
M R. KAYANI, J
A. R. Niazi, for Petitioner. M. A. Khan, for
Respondent

Mst. FAIZ BEGUM and othersvsMUHAMMAD BASHIR

Law: Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887

Section: 25

Law: Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908)

Section: O. XX, r. 4

Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908),O. XX, r. 4-Judgment of Court of Small Causes-Should Elucidate points for determination in such detail as to make decision intelligible-Provin�cial Small Cause Courts Act (IX of 1887), s. 25.JUDGMENT M. R. KAYANI, J. The plaintiffs brought a suit against Muhammad Bashir defendant for the. recovery of Rs. 60 as arrears of rent. The defendant pleaded that he was not a tenant of the house which was under possessory mortgage with one Charagh Dir. and that Charagh Din had let it out to Sardar Muhammad and Muhammad Jan in two parts. The plaintiffs relied upon a rent note which the defendant had executed in their favour. The execution was admitted but it was pleaded that possession had not been obtained under that note because other parties were in possession. The suit was tried as a small cause suit and dismissed with the following order:- "The only question for determination in this case is whether the defendant was let in possession of the house in dispute and is liable to pay rent? My finding on this issue is against the plaintiffs. The suit is; therefore, dismissed with costs" It was argued that this was not a proper order according to law, and reliance was placed on A. I. R. 1943 Bombay 416. Now, Order 20 rule 4, sub-rule (1) of the Code of Civil Procedure expressly lays down that judgments of a Court of Small Causes need not contain more than the points for determination and the decision thereon, whereas under sub-rule (2) it has been made clear that judgments of other Courts should also contain the reasons for the decision. At the same time section 25 of the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act provides that the High Court, for the purpose of satisfy�ing itself that a decree or order made in any case decided by a Court of Small Causes was according to law, may call for the case and pass, such order with respect thereto as it thinks fit. It was observed in the Bombay case aforesaid that if the High Court is empowered to satisfy itself that a decree or order of the judge of a Small Cause Court was in accordance with law or not, "a correlative duty is impliedly cast on that judge…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register