Case Details

Citation(s)
1950 SLG 57 1950 SLD 57 1950 PLD 115
Lahore High Court
Criminal Appeal No. 649 of 1949, decided on 19th January,1950 from the order of Additional Sessions Judge, Lahore atSheikhupura, dated 4th July 1949, convicting the appellant
MUHAMMAD, JAN AND M. R. KAYANI, JJ
Dr. Tassaduque Hussain, and Mian Hamid-ud-Din, for Appellant. Vir Sen Sawhney, for Advocate-General for
Respondent

MUHAMMAD ZAMANvsTHE CROWN

Law: Pakistan Penal Code, 1860

Section: 324,149,302

Evidence Act (1 of 9872),S. 133 and S. 114, ill. (b)-�Approver's evidence-Peed not be corroborated in every detail-Circumstantial evidence connecting accused with crime enough.-�Measure of corroboration.It is well settled law that the evidence of an approver need not be corroborated in every detail of the crime; for, if that were so, the evidence of an approver would be unnecessary. Moreover, corroboration need not be by direct evidence. It is sufficient if there is circumstantial evidence to show the connection of the accused with the crime and the corroborative evidence need not; by itself, be sufficient for conviction. All that is necessary is that the story of the approver should be corroborated in some particulars showing, or tending to show, that the accused was concerned in the commission of the crime.One of the accused produced a knife with which the injuries on the deceased could have been inflicted. It was found to be stained with blood by the Chemical Examiner though the report of the Imperial Serologist was not on the record and the origin of the blood had not been determined. A pair of country made shoes such as that mentioned by the tracker, was recovered from his suit case. He produced currency notes worth Rs. 550, the amount stated by the approver to have been paid to him, and his turban was stained with blood.Held that the evidence of the approver was sufficiently corro�borated particularly by the knife produced by the accused from a watercourse.It was proved as regards another accused that she took the deceased from the house to Nankana Sahib and after that he was not seen alive. She produced Rs. 600, which was stated by the approver to have been taken by her as her share. She produced it from a tin cylinder buried in the wall of her brother's house. These facts constituted material corroboration of the approver's evidence against her.JUDGMENT The prosecution case is that Muhammad Khan deceased, aged about 60 years, had a daughter named Nur Fatima, of marriageable age, from his wife Mst. Ghulam Aishan, accused, who is about 35 years of age. He wished to marry Nur Fatima to one Muhammad Zamman, son of Suleman. Mst. Ghulam Aishan…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register