| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1950 SLG 34 1950 SLD 34 1950 PLD 239 |
Lahore High Court
Criminal Appeal No. 318 of 1949, decided on 19th April, 1950 from the order of Additional Sessions Judge, Montgomery, dated 12th January, 1949
MUHAMMAD SHARIF AND SHABIR AHMAD, JJ
Manzur Qadir, for Appellant. Muhammad Sharif, Assistant to Advocate-General, for Crown
Criminal Appeal No. 318 of 1949, decided on 19th April, 1950 from the order of Additional Sessions Judge, Montgomery, dated 12th January, 1949
MUHAMMAD SHARIF AND SHABIR AHMAD, JJ
Manzur Qadir, for Appellant. Muhammad Sharif, Assistant to Advocate-General, for Crown
MUHAMMAD ALI
VS
CROWN
Law: Criminal Procedure Code (V of 1898)
Section: 417,439,342,342(1)
(a) Criminal Procedure Code (V of 1898) Ss. 417, 439-High Court's power to set aside order of acquittal on appeal or revision. An order of acquittal cannot be altered into one of conviction by the High Court except where an appeal by the Provincial Government has been presented under section 417 of the Criminal Procedure Code, but the High Court can, in exercise of its powers of revision, set aside an order of acquittal and order a retrial. In cases where the order of acquittal is passed by a Court not having jurisdiction or is based on an incomplete record of evidence, or is against any provision of law, no difficulty arises because in such cases the order of acquittal can be set aside and a ,re-trial ordered without any prejudice being caused to the accused person. In cases where the order of acquittal is passed by a Court of competent jurisdiction and in which the entire evidence for the prosecution has been recorded, the High Court should be reluctant to order a re-trial in revision because such an order means practically a direction to the Subordinate Court to which the case is sent, to convict though, because of the absence of an appeal under section 417 of the Criminal Procedure Code, the High Court itself would not be competent to alter the acquittal into conviction. (b) Criminal Procedure Code (V of 1898) S. 342-Provisions not complied with -Accused not -asked to explain circumstances appearing in evidence against him-Case remanded. The second part of subsection (1) of section 342, Criminal Procedure Code is imperative and appears to have been enacted to give the accused person an opportunity to show to the Court that what is being considered to be against him, is in reality not so. Where the accused person was not asked to explain the circumstances appearing against him, the mandatory provisions of Section 342, Criminal Procedure Code, cannot be said to have been complied with. A. I. R. 1933 P. C. 124 referred to. JUDGMENT SHABIR AHMAD, J.-Muhammad Ali son of Fateh Ali, Nura son of Ahmad and Mamoon son of Begu, along with three others, were trade by Mr. S A. Nasir, Additional Sessions Judge, Montgomery, for an offence under section 396 read…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492