Case Details

Citation(s)
1991 SLG 2020 1991 SLD 2020 1991 PLC 1181
Service Tribunal, Sindh
Appeals Nos. 2 of 1989,112 of 1988 and 7 of 1989, decided on 9th October, 1989.
MUNAWAR ALI KHAN, CHAIRMAN AND MOBEEN AHMAD KHAN, MEMBER
M.R. Khanzada and Hasan Akbar for Appellants. Abdul Ghafoor Mangi, A.A.G. for
Respondents.

ZULFIQAR ALI and 2 others

VS

ZULFIQAR ALI and 2 others vs DIRECTOR-GENERAL AE & W M SINDH HYDERABAD and another

Law:

Section:

Sindh Civil Servants (Efficiency and Discipline) Rules, 1973-- ---R. 5---Termination of services---Appellants' services were terminated for reason that they had submitted forged documents in support of their qualifications---Appellants challenged order of their termination---When forgery came to the light on verification of original documents of qualification by Selection Committee, appellants emphatically refuted the charge in reply to show-cause' notice---Evidence on record showing that documents which were allegedly produced by appellants at time of their appointment did not tally with original documents in respect of their qualification---For regularization of appointment when appellants appeared before the Departmental Selection Committee, there too, they could not prove that they possessed the required qualifications although no evidence existed for forgery allegedly committed by them---Held, since appellants lacked requisite qualifications, no interference was called for in order of their termination---Charge of forgery having not been proved, order of termination was allowed to stand for want of prescribed qualifications instead of forgery of documents . . JUDGMENT By this judgment we propose to dispose of three appeals; Appeals Nos. 2 of 1989, 112 of 1988 and No.7 of 1989, respectively filed by Messrs Zulfiqar Ali, Abdul Qayoom and Ghulam Anwar. All the three appellants were sub-Engineers (BS-11), when their services were terminated for the reason that they had submitted forged documents in support of their qualifications. They challenged their orders of termination in departmental appeals and after waiting for usual period of 90 days, they filed the aforementioned appeals before this Tribunal. Appellant Zulfiqar Ali was appointed as Sub-Engineer on ad hoc basis by the Director, on Farm Water Management Project, Sindh, Hyderabad (hereinafter referred as the Director) vide his order, dated 21-1-1985, Subsequently by order dated 7th April, 1985 of the Director his services were transferred to the Command Water Management Project and he was posted under the Assistant Director, Tharushah. On 2-7-1988 vacant posts of Sub-­Engineers in Command Water…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492