Law:

Section:

Punjab Service Tribunals Act (IX of 1974)-- --S.4--Police Rules, 1934, 8.13.7--Constables suitable for lower school course--Selection procedure for list 'B'--Entry to list 'B' limited to seats available for such course--Rationale behind selection of candidates for lower school course, held, was that only those constables' names who were likely to be sent up for course should be brought on list ' B'--Rules were framed with a view to select the best of the talent available and to pick up top-notchers for training from the latest list--List 'B' having been prepared in accordance with rules, and merit wise, no interference was called for by Service Tribunal-Appeals being devoid of merit were dismissed in circumstances. P L D 1985 S C 195 and 1986 P L C (QS) 335 ref. M.A. Riaz for Appellants. A.G. Humayun District Attorney for Respondents. Date of hearing: 3rd February, 1988. JUDGMENT IHSANUL HAQ CHAUDHRY (CHAIRMAN).--These are seven connected appeals. The brief facts compelling the appellants to have resort to present appeals under section 4 of the Punjab Service Tribunal Act, 1974 are that the appellants are all serving as Constables. They took examination held by respondent No.l for including their names in list 'B'. The grievance of appellants Nazir Ahmad, Muhammad Tariq, Muhammad Arshad and Nazir Ahmad is that in spite of the fact that they not only passed in individual papers but also obtained the prescribed aggregate marks and were declared successful but still their names did not find way in the list 'B' while the grievance of other three appellants is that they were failing in one paper only, therefore, were entitled to grace marks as given to the other candidates more particularly Allah Wasaya and Abbas Ali. We are giving below the sum and substance of the grievance of the appellants in order to clearly understand their view-point:- General Law Police Rules G. P. Knowledge Parade Total Remarks marks 360 Total Total Marks 90 Marks 90 Total 90 Total 90 Total Pass marks 45 Pass marks 45 Pass marks 45 Pass marks 45 Pass marks 45 Marks Obtained Marks Obtained Marks Obtained Marks Obtained Precedent cases 43 74 65 41 223 Pass 34 78 66 56 234 Pass Appellants:…

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492