Case Details

Citation(s)
1959 SLG 92 1959 SLD 92 1959 PLD 710
Lahore High Court
Regular Second Appeal No. 398 of 1957, decision Date : 10th June, 1959. hearing Date : 10th June, 1959.
MUHAMMAD SHAFI, JUSTICE
Maulvi Siraj ud Din Ahmad for Appellant. Muzar ul Haq for
Respondent.

MST. MULKHAN BIBI

VS

MUHAMMAD WAZIR KHAN

Law: Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908)

Section: 31

(a) Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908), O. XLI, r. 31 --Judgment of Appellate Court dismissing appeal without discussing evidence produced or the contradiction in statements of some of the witnesses Defective. Where the Lower Appellate Court did not discuss the evidence produced by the plaintiff, nor did he discuss the so called con¬tradictory evidence given by some of the witnesses produced by defendant nor did he take the trouble of discussing one of the issues framed in the suit: Held that the of the lower Appellate Court suffered from inherent defects and the conclusions arrived at by him could not be regarded by the High Court in Second Appeal as conclusive. Held, further that the mere statement by the lower appellate Court that he found that the statements made by the different witnesses were contradictory will not be enough unless the alleged contradictions were separately set out in the and the decision given when such contradictions adversely affect the case of a party producing such witnesses. (b) Muhammadan Law ---Dower, Payment of ---Onus lies on person alleging payment, discharge or satisfaction. The onus of the payment, discharge or satisfaction of the dower without which no Muslim marriage is complete, is always on the person alleging such payment, discharge or satisfaction. The fact of the payment is within the knowledge of the person making it, and therefore, he must prove it by positive evidence. (c) Second Appeal --Onus of proof wrongly placed in lower Courts --Case whether and when can be decision date: evidence produced. Where the parties have led their entire evidence on a certain issue in the lower Court, the fact that the burden of proof was wrongly placed should not make any great difference in appeal, but this proposition of law will not apply to cases where no evidence has been led by the parties at all and the question which has to be determined is as to which party should lose. In such cases, the placing of the onus will make material difference. (d) Burden of proof Lies on party asserting positive fact ---Evidence Act (1 of 1872), S. 103. It is the party who asserts a positive fact who should be called upon to prove his assertions…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492