| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1949 SLG 55 1949 SLD 55 1949 PLD 175 |
Lahore High Court
Criminal Appeal No. 313 of 1949, decided on 10th June 1949, from the order of Additional Sessions Judge, Lyallpur, dated 2nd March 1949
MUNIR, C.J. AND KAYANI, J
Muhammad Amin for Appellant. Abdul Aziz Khan, A.A.G. for the Crown
Criminal Appeal No. 313 of 1949, decided on 10th June 1949, from the order of Additional Sessions Judge, Lyallpur, dated 2nd March 1949
MUNIR, C.J. AND KAYANI, J
Muhammad Amin for Appellant. Abdul Aziz Khan, A.A.G. for the Crown
MUHAMMAD SHAFI
VS
THE CROWN
Law: Criminal Procedure Code (V of 1898)
Section: 510
Law: Pakistan Penal Code, 1860
Section: 302,364,34,392
Criminal Procedure Code (V of 1898), S. 510-Imperial Serologist, Calcutta (India) appointed Chemical Examiner to all Provinces of Pakistan and Capital of Federation by Notification, dated 28th/29th March 1949, with effect from 15th August 1947--Notification can have retrospective effect-Report signed not by "Imperial Serologist Calcutta" but by "Second Assistant to Serologist and a Chemical Examiner" held inadmissible. From the language of section 510 of the Code of Criminal Procedure it will have been noticed, that any document purporting to be a report under the hand of a Chemical Examiner to Government, may be used as evidence and since at the present date the Imperial Serologist at Calcutta is Chemical Examiner to the Governments of all the Provinces of Pakistan, the report which is before us today should be construed as a report by the "Chemical Examiner to Government" and admitted in evidence, provided it purports to be under ,the hand of a Chemical Examiner. The difficulty, however, is that while by the Notification aforesaid, it is the Imperial Serologist at Calcutta, not the Chemical Examiner, who has been appointed Chemical Examiner to the Governments of all the Provinces of Pakistan, the report purports to be under the hand of the "second Assistant to Serologist and a Chemical Examiner to the Government of India." It could be accepted as evidence if it had been signed by the Serologist, not his Assistant. What section 510 of the Code requires is not that it should purport to be report by a Chemical Examiner ; it should in addition be under the hand of a Chemical, Examiner, which clearly means that the signature should purport to be that of a Chemical Examiner appointed by the Government of Pakistan. In this view of the case the report is inadmissible in evidence and the evidence relating to blood stains should be discarded. ORDER KAYANI, J.-This is a murder reference in respect of three persons, namely Muhammad Shafi, Shah Muhammad and Walayat Shah, from the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Lyallpur. Each of the convicts has been sentenced to death under section 302/34, Indian Penal Code, ten years' rigorous imprisonment under section 364/34,…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492