Case Details

Citation(s)
1959 SLG 377 1959 SLD 377 1959 PLD 61
Supreme Court of Pakistan
Civil Appeal No. 80 of 1958, decided on 11th December, 1958.
M. SHAHABUDDIN, A. R. CORNELIUS AND AMIRUDDIN AHMAD, JJ
Jamil Hussain Rizvi, Advocate General, West Pakistan, (M. Z. Kitchlew, Advocate, Supreme Court, with him) instructed by Ijaz Ali, Attorney for Appellant. Shamim Hussain Kadri, Advocate, Supreme Court, instructed by Virasat Hussain Naqvi, Attorney for Resp

THE PROVINCE OF THE PUNJAB--Appellant

VS

MUHAMMAD SHARIF--Respondent

Law:

Section:

Punjab P. W. D., Irrigation Branch Zilladars' Service Rules, 1943, Appendix B (d), rr. 7 (a) & 8 (2)-Finally accepted "candidate Zilladar"-Whether ceases to be a mere candidate-Appointment of person as officiating Zilladar whether amounts to his appointment as Zilladar-Services of such person whether can be dispensed with without show-cause notice-Government of India Act, 1935, S. 240 (3). Under Appendix B (d), Rules 7 (a) and 8 (2) of the Punjab P. W. D., Irrigation Branch- Zilladars' Service Rules, 1943, which provides for appointment of an `accepted candidate Zilladar' the word `or' appearing before Zilladars 2nd Grade and additional Munshis makes it clear that the three appoint­ments named therein are separate and mutually exclusive. This gets further clarification from Part III, Rule 8 (1) of the said Rules, which provides that Zilladars of the 2nd Grade shall be appointed on probation for a period of two years in the first instance. The explanation added to this Rule also makes it clear that the appointments of officiating Zilladars and Zilladars of the 2nd Grade an probation are not only two different appointments but that the officiating appointment precedes the appointment on probation. Before a candidate is appointed to the grade of Zilladar 2nd Grade he cannot be said to be appointed to the service. This is clear from Rule 7 (a) of the Rules. It follows, therefore, that a person continues to be a candidate until he is appointed 2nd Grade Zilladar and his service is liable to be terminated under clause 3 of Appendix B of the Rules. Even if a person is actually appointed a 2nd Grade Zilladar on probation, he could still be liable to have his services dispensed with in the same manner under Rule 8 (2) of the Rules. An accepted "candidate Zilladar" cannot be said to be holding a civil post in Pakistan and when he is discharged from service he is not entitled to protection under section 240 (3) of the Government of India Act, 1935. Even if a person is appointed 2nd Grade Zilladar on probation, his discharge as provided by Rule 14.10 in Chapter XIV of the Civil Services Rules (Punjab), Volume I, would not amount to removal or dismissal from service and…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492