| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1959 SLG 37 1959 SLD 37 1959 PLD 243 |
Lahore High Court
Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 2044 of 1958, decision Date : 16th January 1959. Dates of hearing: 5-1 1959 and 12 1 1959.
SHABIR AHMAD, JUSTICE, MASUD AHMAD, JUSTICE
M. Anwar for Petitioner. Jamil Husain Rizvi, Advocate General and Ihsan ul Haq for
Respondents.
Criminal Miscellaneous Petition No. 2044 of 1958, decision Date : 16th January 1959. Dates of hearing: 5-1 1959 and 12 1 1959.
SHABIR AHMAD, JUSTICE, MASUD AHMAD, JUSTICE
M. Anwar for Petitioner. Jamil Husain Rizvi, Advocate General and Ihsan ul Haq for
Respondents.
CHAUDHRI MANZOOR ELAHI
VS
THE STATE AND OTHERS
Law:
Section:
(a) Laws (Continuance in Force) Order (Post Proclamation I of 7958), S. 3 (iii) High Court not precluded from issuing appropriate writ against order of a Summary Military Court if the order itself was without jurisdiction High Court entitled to hear arguments on question of jurisdiction. Held, that although the language of paragraph 3 of the Laws (Continuance in Force) Order (I of 1958) was in extremely general terms it was not in all cases that the jurisdiction of the High Court with regard to a or order of a Military Court had been taken away. While the High Court will have no juris¬diction to determine whether or not a finding, or order of a Military Court was justified, there was no ouster of jurisdiction where the order of the Military Court was without jurisdiction. If a Military Court passes a sentence on a person it could not try, or tries an offence it was not given the power to try or passes a sentence it was not competent to pass, the order will be without jurisdiction and will not enjoy the immunity from scrutiny by the High Court. This conclusion was based on the well known principle of law that an order which is without jurisdiction cannot be treated as an order for any purpose. It is, however, undeniable that if it could not be found that the order of the Summary Military Court was without jurisdiction, no Court of ordinary jurisdiction including the High Court will have jurisdiction to declare that order to be incorrect in spite of the fact that the findings given by the Military Court were full of gross and inexplicable errors of any dimension or the sentence was considered to be of a severity which appeared to be uncalled for. The question whether the evidence before the Summary Military Court justified the conviction of the detenu would not be open to determination by the High Court because a Summary Military Court can try all offences and persons by virtue of clause (a) of Regulation No. 1 A. of Martial Law Regulations, but whether or not tile sentence assed by the Summary Military Court was with or without jurisdiction is a question which can be gone into by the High Court, and if the conclusion be that the sentence passed by the Summary…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492