Case Details

Citation(s)
1959 SLG 359 1959 SLD 359 1959 PLD 488
Supreme Court of Pakistan
Criminal Appeal No. 47 of 1959, decided on 21st October 1959.
MUHAMMAD MUNIR C.J., M. SHAHABUDDIN, AND A. R. CORNELIUS, JJ
Abdul Majid Asghar, Senior Advocate Supreme Court (Ala Ullah Sajjad, Advocate Supreme Court, with him), instructed by Maqbool Ahmad, Attorney for Appellants. Jamil Husain Rizvi, Advocate General West Pakistan (IftikharulHaq Khan, Advocate Supreme Court, w

JAHAN KHAN and others--Appellants

VS

THE STATE--Respondent

Law:

Section:

(a) Special leave to appeal to Supreme Court-Ground-High Court acquitted some and maintained conviction of others on same evidence-Leave granted-Constitution of Pakistan (1956), Art. 160. (b) Evidence-High Court on same evidence acquitting some accused and maintaining convictions of others-Supreme Court on appeal upheld order of High Court re: accused whose convictions had been maintained-(Quaere) Order of acquittal whether improper. (c) Witness-Interested-Statement of disinterested witness may be read as corroboration. JUDGMENT MUHAMMAD MUNIR, C. J.-This is a criminal appeal from a judgment of the High Court of West Pakistan at Lahore. Six persons were convicted by the Sessions Judge, Gujranwala for the murder of Ali Ahmad, alleged to have been committed on the morning of 18th June 1957, in village Wadala in the house of Jahan Khan. On appeal the High Court acquitted Bahadur and Khushi but upheld the conviction and the death sentences of Jahan Khan, Muhammad Saleh, Muhammad Shah and Rehmat who were granted special leave by this Court to appeal, on the ground A that on the same evidence the High Court had acquitted some and maintained the convictions of others. Ali Ahmad is said to have been murdered by the appellants because he himself had murdered one Muhammad Bashir, brother of Muhammad Shafi and brother-in-law of Jahan Khan appellants, and his prosecution had failed. According to the evidence, on the day of the occurrence Ali Ahmad was going with one Karam P. W. through a village street when the six accused persons of whom Muhammad Saleh was armed with a hatchet attacked him. Rahmat caught hold of him while the others started beating him with sticks and a hatchet. The victim succeeded in extricating himself from Rahmat's grip and from the shop of Fazal Muhammad butcher ran towards the shop of Fazal cobbler where he was again caught by Rahmat and beaten by the others. From there he was lifted and taken to the house of Jahan Khan where his head was practically severed with a spade by Muhammad Shah at the instance of Jahan Khan. There were four eye-witnesses of the occurrence who gave evidence for the prosecution. These were Karam, Nazar Muhammad. Ghulam Qadir…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492