| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1959 SLG 358 1959 SLD 358 1959 PLD 387 |
Supreme Court of Pakistan
Civil Appeals Nos. 18-D, 19-D, 20-D, 21-D, 22-D, 23-D, 24-D and 25-D of 1958, decided on 9th July 1959. dates of hearing : Heard at Dacca on May 11, 12, 13, 14 And Heard at Lahore on June 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 20 and 22, 1959
MUHAMMAD MUNIR, C.J., M. SHAHABUDDIN, A. R. CORNELIUS, AMIRUDDIN AHMAD AND S. A. RAHMAN, JJ
A. K. Brohi and A. B. Mahmud Hossain, Senior Advocates Supreme Court (A. Hakim and Rao Muhammad Ashfaq Khan, Advocates Supreme Court with them), instructed by Siddique & Co., Attorneys for Appellants. H. S. Suhrawardy, Senior Advocate Supreme Court (Nasim
Civil Appeals Nos. 18-D, 19-D, 20-D, 21-D, 22-D, 23-D, 24-D and 25-D of 1958, decided on 9th July 1959. dates of hearing : Heard at Dacca on May 11, 12, 13, 14 And Heard at Lahore on June 11, 12, 15, 16, 17, 20 and 22, 1959
MUHAMMAD MUNIR, C.J., M. SHAHABUDDIN, A. R. CORNELIUS, AMIRUDDIN AHMAD AND S. A. RAHMAN, JJ
A. K. Brohi and A. B. Mahmud Hossain, Senior Advocates Supreme Court (A. Hakim and Rao Muhammad Ashfaq Khan, Advocates Supreme Court with them), instructed by Siddique & Co., Attorneys for Appellants. H. S. Suhrawardy, Senior Advocate Supreme Court (Nasim
1. THE PROVINCE OF EAST PAKISTAN and 2. THE SECRETARY, FINANCE AND REVENUE (REVENUE) DEPARTMENT, EAST PAKISTAN, DACCA
VS
(1) MD. MEHDI ALI KHAN---Respondent Civil Appeal No. 19-D of 1958. (2) Syed MUHAMMAD ALI--Respondent Civil Appeal No. 20-D of 1
Law:
Section:
(a) Constitution of Pakistan (1956), Art. 157 (1)-Substantial question of law as to interpretation of Constitution-High Court's certificate re: appeal to Supreme Court-"Third Judge" (hearing case on difference of opinion between two Judges) competent to grant-Government of India Act, 1935, S. 205-Letters Patent (Dacca), cl. 36 : [Per Muhammad Munir, C. J. ; Cornelius, J., (contra) Per Muhammad Munir, C. J.-It is a common practice in the Dacca High Court, based on the practice of the Calcutta High Court while section 205 of the Government of India Act 1935, was in force, for a single Judge or a Division Bench, different from the `Appellate Court', to grant a certificate in cases where a substantial question relating to the interpretation of the Constitution is raised and decided. This certificate is given without any express direction of the Chief Justice for the constitution of a Bench for the purpose. The rule should not be different where on a difference of opinion the case is referred to and decided in accordance with the opinion of the third Judge. Per Cornelius, J., (contra).-"The certificate is required by Article 157 to be granted by the High Court and I conceive that by the expression `High Court' is meant in any particular case, a Judge or Judges of the High Court functioning under the rules of the High Court and under the general control of the Chief Justice as exercised by means of special orders e.g., orders constituting Division Benches for the purpose of grant of such a certificate. I feel no difficulty in coming to the conclusion that the position of Mr. Justice Ispahani ("Third Judge") in relation to the case must be placed within the terms of clause 36 of the Letters Patent, and so placed, he could not be regarded as the High Court in respect of the decision. Therefore, the whole proceeding, which has resulted by the grant .of the certificate by him was, in my view, ultra vires. A certificate could only have been granted within the rules of the Supreme Court and the High Court. Rule 1 of Order XII of the Rules of this Court provides as follows: - "The provisions of Order XLV of the Code and of any rules made for the purpose by the High Court…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492