Case Details

Citation(s)
1959 SLG 225 1959 SLD 225 (1959) 35 ITR 103
Bombay High Court
IT REFERRANCE No. 36 OF 1957, MARCH 11, 1958
CHAGLA, C.J. AND S.T. DESAI, J.

Deprecated: str_replace(): Passing null to parameter #3 ($subject) of type array|string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 395

Commissioner of IncomE tax

v.

Donald Miranda

Law:

Section:

JUDGMENT Chagla, CJ.-The question that we have to consider in this reference lies in a very narrow compass. It is not a question which is easy to decide. The assessment year of the assessee is 1945-46 and the year of account is the year ending 21st March, 1945. During this year, the firm of three partners, James Miranda, Donald Miranda and Mrs. N.Q. Miranda, were carrying on business as wine merchants. Their income for the year was assessed to tax and they were also charged excess profits tax upon their profits of the business for the chargeable accounting period ending on the 1st of April, 1944. The firm was succeeded on the 25th of March, 1945, by a limited liability company, S.S. Miranda Ltd. For the assessment year 1945-46, the firm claimed the benefit of section 25(4) contending that no tax was payable on its profits of the said business for the period from the 1st of April, 1944, to the 24th of March, 1945. The claim of the assessee was considered by the Department and benefit was given to the assessee of section 25(4). The firm had paid excess profits tax in respect of the chargeable accounting period 1st of April, 1944 to the 24th of March, 1945, and had also made a deposit under the provisions of section 10 of the Indian Finance Act, 1942, read with section 2 of the Excess Profits Tax Ordinance, 1943 and had thus become entitled to repayment of a portion of the excess profits tax paid by them. The Department brought the amount, which was repayable to the firm, to tax under the provisions of section 11(11) of the Indian Finance Act of 1946. The contention of the assessee was that the repayment of this amount was profits of his business within the meaning of section 10 of the Income-tax Act, and they were not liable to pay any tax in respect of this amount by reason of section 25(4) of the Act. The Tribunal by a majority decided the matter in favour of the assessee and the Commissioner of Income-tax has now come on this reference. The majority of the members of the Tribunal, in coming to the decision that they did, largely relied on certain English decisions. This is an appropriate case where the note of warning, which has so often been sounded in the…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492