Case Details

Citation(s)
1949 SLG 32 1949 SLD 32 1949 PLD 361
Lahore High Court
First Appeal No. 51 of 1944, decided on 13th June 1949 fromthe decree of the Court of Sub-Judge, First Class, Lyallpur,dated the 12th February 1944
CORNELIUS AND KAYANI, JJ
S. A. Kareem for Appellants. Zahur-ud-din Pal for
Respondents

MIRU and BIRUvsNURMUHAMMAD and others

Law: Limitation Act, 1908

Section: FirstSch,141

Law: Pakistan Penal Code, 1860

Section: 147,447

Law: Punjab Tenancy Act, (XVI of 1887)

Section: 45,14

(a) Adverse possession against Muhammadan widow's life estate------Held, not adverse against one having an independent right to succeed to widow on her death or remarriage-Limitation Act (IX of 1908), First Sch. Art. 141.A person prescribing for title against a Muhammadan widow in enjoyment of a life-estate could not at the same time be regarded as prescribing for title against one entitled to succeed on the death or remarriage of the widow. Article 141 in First Schedule of Limitation Act (IX of 1908) provided a period of 12 years' limitation for a Muhammadan entitled to the possession of immovable property on the death of a Muhammandan female the terminus being the date of such death.(b) Res judicata-------Earlier Revenue Court's decisions not so clear as they should be-Avoiding matters coming subsequently before Civil Court and failing to notice evidence of Revenue Records-Held, it was unsafe to place decision of subsequent civil case on plea of res judicata.We find on a careful examination of the various decisions of the Revenue Courts that the decisions of those Courts are by no means as clear as they should be if they are to he regarded as res judicata in a civil case.In some respects the findings of the revenue authorities avoid decisions on matters which are now before the Courts, and in other respects they fail to take notice of evidence existing on the revenue records which was highly relevant to the decision which they were recording and, therefore, it seems that it would be unsafe to place decision of the present case on the basis of any plea of res judicata arisising out of these earlier revenue decisions.(c) Symbolical possession delivered where actual possession could have been asked for or could have been delivered---------Minor irregularities in proceedings not materially affecting degree of publicity-Symbolical possession, held effectively determined pre­-existing adverse possession.Where the nature of possession delivered was such as the condition of each kila allowed of i.e., those which were vacant were given in actual possession and as for those which were under crop symbolical possession was given.Held, there can be no doubt whatsoever…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492