Case Details

Citation(s)
1959 SLG 147 1959 SLD 147 (1959) 36 ITR 25 (1959) 1 TAX 28
Bombay High Court
IT REFERENCE No. 12 OF 1958, OCTOBER 1, 1958
S.T. DESAI AND K.T. DESAI, JJ.

Deprecated: str_replace(): Passing null to parameter #3 ($subject) of type array|string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 395

Commissioner of Income tax

v.

Shoorji Vallabhdas & Co.

Law: Income Tax Act, 1922

Section: 10(2)(xv)

JUDGMENT S.T. Desai, J.-This reference raises a question of some difficulty and importance and the income in dispute relates to managing agency commission. In the matter out of which it arises there was a difference of opinion between the Accountant Member and the Judicial Member constituting the Tribunal and on a reference to the President the decision was in favour of the assessee. The three judgments turned a good deal on the effect of a decision of this court. The arguments before us also have revolved round that decision almost as a spindle and -it will be necessary for us to ascertain the ratio decidendi of that case. Of this more hereafter. The assessee, in this reference under section 66(1) made at the instance of the Commissioner of Income-tax, is the firm of Messrs. Shoorji Vallabhdas & Co. The assessment year is 1948-49 and the previous year ended on 31st March, 1948. During that previous year the assessee firm consisted of three partners and its business consisted of acting as managing agents to several shipping companies. We are concerned in this reference with only two of the shipping companies, viz., the Malabar Steamship Co. Ltd. and the New Dholera Steamship Co. Ltd. Under agreements with the two companies, themanaging agents were entitled to 10 per cent. commission on the freight charged to shippers. According to the agreements with the two companies, the assessee firm would have become entitled to claim commission of Rs. 1,71,885 from the Malabar Steamship Co. Ltd. and Rs. 2,56,815 from the Dholera Steamship Co. for the period April 1, 1947, to December 31, 1947, which was the period of first 9 months of the relevant assessment year 1948-49. In the books of account of the assessee credit entries were made relating to this commission and corresponding debit entries were made in the accounts of the shipping companies maintained in their books by the assessee. It does not appear from the statement that any such entries were made in the account books maintained by the shipping companies. But later on, it appears, the assessee company agreed to receive remuneration at 2½% in the circumstances to which we shall presently advert. Shorn of…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492