Law:

Section:

Civil service- --- Adverse remarks -Mala fide-Double reporting--Report covering period of more than 4 months in particular year for which reported officer worked under Reporting Officer already written and countersigned by respective countersigning officer Such report containing no adverse remarks and grading him inter alia "fit for promotion"-Another report described as "special report" for entire particular year written by same officer, though had supervised work of reported officer for about 4 months period covered by previous report - Such report also countersigned by same countersigning authority and grading him as unfit for promotion" No reasons for obtaining such special report indicated-Second contradictory and adverse report in circum­ stances, held, mala fide intention of reporting and countersigning officers to harm reported officer (appellant) hence directed to be expunged and removed from A. C. R. of appellant Service Tribunals Act (LXX of 1973), S. 4. Date of hearing : 29th April, 1984. JUDGMENT ABDOR RASHID (MEMBER).-Facts of the case are that a confi­dential report was initiated on the appellant covering the period 13th August, 1981 to 31st December, 1981. This report was written by Mr. Azmat Hussain, Director Telegraphs, Southern Region while the appellant was employed as Assistant General Manager 11 S. T. R., Karachi, in his own pay and grade 17. The reporting officer graded the appellant as average and declared him fit for promotion as well as fit for retention (after 25 years of service). The counter­signing officer, Mr. Wali Muhammad, General Manager, Southern Telecom. Region, Karachi, too, concurred with the report and considered the appellant to be fit both for retention after 25 years of service as well as for promotion to grade 18. 2. While the above report was in the field another report was initiated on the appellant covering the period 1st January, 1981 to 31st December, 1981. This report was captioned as Special Report 1981 and had been written in response to telegram No. S/M-221/COLL-11, D. P. C. dated 2nd February, 1982. This report, too, was initiated by Mr. Azmat Hussain, Director, Telegraphs, Southern Telecom. Region, Karachi…

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492