Case Details

Citation(s)
1958 SLG 286 1958 SLD 286 (1958) 34 ITR 684
Bombay High Court
IT REFERENCE No. 80 OF 1957, MARCH 20, 1958
CHAGLA, C.J. S.T. DESAI, J.
N.A. Palkhivala for the Applicant. G.N. Joshi and R.J. Joshi for the
Respondent

Ram Pratap Ramdeo

v.

Commissioner of Income tax

Law:

Section:

Section 9 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [Corresponding to section 4(1) of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922] - Income deemed to be accrue or arise in India -Assessee's head office was in Indian state and it had also two factories in taxable territories - During previous years prior to relevant assessment year assessee had business losses - In relevant assessment year it made profits - Tribunal treated above profit as remittance from taxable territories and stated that previous losses were adjusted in capital account - Whether since it was not clear whether amount in question was result of losses being carried forward from year to year in books of account of assessee or this had been arrived at merely from a consolidated statement which assessee submitted, Tribunal was to be directed to submit a supplemental statement of case - Held, yes FACTS The assessee's head office was at 'J'. (Indian State). He had two ginning and pressing factories in the state styled as 'K' and 'B'. The assessee maintained the factories and separate accounts for 'K' and 'B'. The profits relating to these factories were transferred to the head office from time to time. No remittance was made from the 'K' or 'B' to India. The total profits from 'K' and 'B' in the three respective years amount to Rs. 26,350, Rs. 54,000 and Rs. 31,000. The ITO brought to assessment the total profits which accrued to the assessee in the state in the year in which they accrued. The AAC held that there was no remittance direct from 'K' and 'B', there was no remittance of profit to India. The AAC therefore, allowed the assessee's appeal and held that there was no remittance of profit from head office to India. Appeal to the Tribunal was dismissed. However, it was contended by the assessee that it was not clear whether the balance of Rs. 92,000 was the result of losses being carried forwards from year to year in the books of account of the assessee or this had been arrived at merely from a consolidated statement which the assessee submitted. On reference: HELD The Tribunal had not either considered properly or had not appreciated the legal implications of the fact that there was a loss at the commencement of the…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492