Case Details

Citation(s)
1958 SLG 20 1958 SLD 20 1958 PLD 86
Supreme Court of Pakistan

M. SHAHABUDDIN, A. C.J., A. R. CORNELIUS, MUHAMMAD SHARIF AND AMIRUDDIN AHMAD, JJ
A. K. Brohi, Senior Advocate, Supreme Court (Riaz Hashmi, Advocate, Supreme Court with him) instructed by S. A. Majid, Attorney for Appellant. S. A. Mahmud, Advocate, Supreme Court, instructed by Ijaz Ali, Attorney

HASSANALLY KHAN G. AGHA

VS

PROVINCE OF WEST PAKISTAN

Law:

Section:

The question was whether appellant was entitled to two additional pensions, i.e. both under the High Court Judges Order, 1937, para. 19 (3) and the Civil Service Regulations, Article 475-A, Held, that the description attached, in paragraph 19 (3), High Court Judges Order, 1937, to the supplementary pension which a member of a Civil Service may claim in respect of service rendered as a judge of a High Court is the same as is used in Article 475-A of the Civil Service Regulations. The amount of the special additional pension is expressed in practically the same words in the two provisions. Since paragraph 19 of the High Court Judges Order, 1937 expressly refers to "the rules of his civil service" and Article 475-A mentions "Chief Court judges who may take a pension under the rules in this part of the Regulations", there can be no doubt that the two instruments are intended to be, and should be construed together. Where two provisions relating to the same matter are being construed together, the rule is that they should as far as possible be construed consistently with each other. The employment of the same expression "special additional pension" and the fixation of the amount in the same terms as in Article 475-A lead to the conclusion that by paragraph 19, no distinct pension other than that given by Article 475-A was being provided. The High Court Judges Order 1937, did not intend to give two special additional pensions, but only one. The Civil Service Regulations provide for only one special additional pension admissible to an officer whose qualifying service has been spent in lower grade as well as in upper grade appointments. Paragraph 19 of the High Court Judges Order, on its true construction, makes a similar provision in relation to a member of a civil service who has risen to the post of judge of a High Court and elects to take a pension otherwise than under the Third Schedule to that Order. Any construction which has the effect of furnishing such an officer with two special additional pensions is inadmissible. Separate provision in the High Court Judges Order was necessary because without repeating the provision, the High Court Judges Order, 1937 would…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492