| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1958 SLG 199 1958 SLD 199 (1958) 33 ITR 692 |
Mysore High Court
WRIT PETITION No. 10 OF 1956, DECEMBER 4, 1957
S. R. DAS GUPTA, C, J. AND SOMNATH IYER, J.
T.V. Viswanatha Aiyar and S. P. Bhat for the Petitioner. D.M. Chandrasekhar and G. R. Ethirajulu Naidu for the
Respondent
WRIT PETITION No. 10 OF 1956, DECEMBER 4, 1957
S. R. DAS GUPTA, C, J. AND SOMNATH IYER, J.
T.V. Viswanatha Aiyar and S. P. Bhat for the Petitioner. D.M. Chandrasekhar and G. R. Ethirajulu Naidu for the
Respondent
K. Sadianna Shetty
v.
Second Additional Income Tax Officer
Law:
Section:
Section 271(1)(c), read with section 189 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 [Corresponding to section 28(1)(c), read with section 44 of the Indian Income-tax Act, 1922] - Penalty - For concealment of income - Assessment year 1951-52 - Whether, even if section 28 of 1922 Act is attracted to section 44 of 1922 Act, even then no penalty can be imposed on a dissolved firm nor can penalty imposed on such a firm be charged against its partners - Held, yes FACTS The petitioner was one of the three partners of a firm which was dissolved on 18-11-1953. The said partnership had come into existence in the year 1935. On 31-5-1952, an assessment was made under section 23(3) of 1922 Act on the said firm for the relevant assessment year. On appeals, the AAC and thereupon the Tribunal reduced the amount of assessable income. After the completion of assessment, the ITO had also initiated penalty proceedings under section 28 of 1922 Act against the firm and, ultimately on 9-3-1956, the penalty was imposed. As by that time, the firm had been dissolved, a notice of demand under section 29 of 1922 Act dated 16-3-1957, was issued to the petitioner on behalf of dissolved firm. The petitioner by filing instant petition challenged the validity of order imposing penalty and the impugned notice of demand. HELD When a firm is dissolved and has thus ceased to exist in the eye of law no penalty can be imposed on it. According to section 28 of 1922 Act, penalty is imposed on the person who has failed to furnish the return of his total income or has concealed the particulars of his income as the case may be. It is such person who is clearly made liable to pay the penalty mentioned in the said section. In instant case, the person, who was said to have concealed the particulars of its income, was the firm and section 28 of 1922 Act made such firm liable to pay by way of penalty the amount mentioned in the said section. Unlike section 23(5) of the 1922 Act, section 28 of the said Act nowhere makes the partners liable for payment of the penalty which has been imposed on the firm. Clause (d) of section 28(1) clearly indicates that, although a registered firm itself is not made liable-but its partners…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492