| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1958 SLG 172 1958 SLD 172 1958 PLD 296 |
Lahore High Court
Second Appeal No. 139 of 1955, decided on 30th January 1958, from the decree of the Court of Chaudhry Muhammad Ali,
AKHLAQUE HUSSAIN, J
Said Akbar Khan for Appellants. Raja Muhammad Akram for
Respondents
Second Appeal No. 139 of 1955, decided on 30th January 1958, from the decree of the Court of Chaudhry Muhammad Ali,
AKHLAQUE HUSSAIN, J
Said Akbar Khan for Appellants. Raja Muhammad Akram for
Respondents
MUHAMMAD ASHRAF and another
VS
MAHBOOB SULTAN and 2 others
Law:
Section:
Custom (Punjab)-Alienation-Decree in reversioners' suit for possession-Whether separate appeals against various reversioners competent-Four reversioners' suit for possession of land, invalidly gifted, decreed-Donee inadvertently impleading in appeal only three reversioners-Subsequent appeal against fourth revesioner dismissed as time-barred-Original appeal may not be dismissed on that account. A suit by four reversioners, for possession of land, based on the invalidity of a gift under custom, was decreed by the trial Court. The defendants preferred an appeal but omitted to implead one of the four decree-holder reversioners as one of the respondents. Against the revesioner not impleaded in the appeal they subsequently filed another appeal which was dismissed as time-barred. The appellate Court basing its decision on dismissal of the subsequent appeal also dismissed the earlier appeal on the ground that the decree "could not be split up and challenged only against three of them." Held, that the dismissal of the subsequent appeal could not, in law, lead to the dismissal of the appeal against the three other reversioners. Since the subject-matters of the two appeals, that is to say, the share of the respondent in the subsequent appeal on the one hand and those of the three respondents in the earlier appeal in the property of the donor were separable, there could be no conflict between the decree in the subsequent appeal and the decree which could have been passed in the earlier appeal. It was not a case of two decrees in respect of the same property and therefore the question of any conflict between them could not arise. The possibility of contradiction or conflict in the s was immaterial. Sant Singh v. Gulab Singh A I R 1928 Lah. 572 ref. JUDGMENT AKHLAQUE HUSSAIN, J.---These two appeals arise out of a suit brought by Mahboob Sultan, Aziz-ur-Rahman and Nazir Ahmad respondents in Regular Second Appeal No. 139, and Abdur Rahman, the respondent in Regular Second Appeal No. 140, against Muhammad Ashraf and his father Sher Zaman, the appellants in both the appeals. The property in dispute in both the appeals was originally owned by one Khan Muhammad who gifted it to…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492