Case Details

Citation(s)
1957 SLG 95 1957 SLD 95 1957 PLD 873
Lahore High Court
Regular First Appeal No. 31 of 1957, decided on 10th September 1957, from the decree of Court of Nur Muhammad, Senior Civil Judge, Jhang, dated 21st February 1957. Pates of hearing : 21st and .25th June 1957
SHABIR AHMAD AND, J. ORTCHESON, JJ
Sardar Muhammad Iqbal, and Aftab Hussain for Appellant. Sh. Bashir Ahmad and Ghias Muhammad for
Respondent

THE AZAD TRANSPORT COMPANY LTD

VS

MUHAMMAD SHARIF

Law: Usurious Loans Act, 1918

Section: 2(1)(2),2(3)(c),3(2)(e)

(a) Hire-purchase----- -----Main feature of transaction-Option of hirer to terminate contract and return article. One of the main features of a transaction of hire-purchase is that the hirer has the option to terminate the contract and return the article which he has been using and of which he might otherwise have become an owner. Where the document evidencing the transaction did not even hint that the hirer could return the hired goods, the transaction was not held to be one of hire-purchase. (b) Usurious Loans Act (X of 1918)---- ----S. 2 (1) (2)- "Loan"-Transaction which is substantially a loan-Powers of Court not circumscribed by apparent terms of document. Subsection (2) of section 2 of Act X of 1918 gives the Court vast powers to examine a transaction and to hold it to be a loan even though the parties had called it by some other name. This power is not circumscribed by the fact that the deed evidencing the transaction did not on the face of it appear to be one relating to a loan. By describing as profit, the return a creditor took on a loan in cash or kind, the nature of the return was not changed the return that a creditor takes is nothing but interest under the provisions of subsection (1) of section 2 of the Usurious Loans Act, 1918, and the fact that it is not described as interest does not change its character. Where the terms of a transaction were :- One A had bought two motor buses for a sum of Rs. 35,000 and was entrusting them to B on the condition that A will be paid Rs. 2,700 per month for sixteen months. The sum of Rs. 2,700 was made up of Rs. 1,500 as part of the principal and Rs. 1,200 as profits. After sixteen instalments of Rs. 2,700 per month had been paid, B had to pay the balance due on the principal, that is, Rs. 11,000, by a certain date and if that were not done, B would be .liable to pay Rs. 1,800 as monthly instalments, of which Rs. 1,500 would represent the principal and Rs. 300 the interest. and this will go on till the amount had been paid off and that it was only when the entire amount had been realised by A that B would become owner of the two buses. It was also provided in the deed that if the entire price of the two buses…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492