Law:

Section:

Service Tribunals Act (LXX of 1973)-- ---S.4-Scope-Adverse remarks in annual confidential report-­Appeal against- Maintainable-Tribunal competent to review assessment made in A.C.R. and to substitute its own opinion for opinion of reporting or countersigning officer who incompetently or wrongly recording same--Reporting Officer grading appellant good and fit for promotion-Countersigning Officer neither scoring out any column of rating part or the remark "good" and assessment "fit for promotion" nor even recording any of his remark in such column-Merely stating that assessment made by Reporting Officer was lenient-Such remarks, held, do not mean that Countersigning Officer was in a disagreement with assessment made by Reporting Officer--Countersigning Officer in general remarks columns record­ing that appellant had reached her ceiling-No reasons for such remarks indicated-Such remarks further found as having been written without sufficient care when viewed in the light of consistently good past record-Ordered to be expunged and entries substituted by Tribunal in light of service record. Secretary, Government of Punjab v. Ahmad Kamaluddin 1981 S C M R 392 ref. Muhammad Aboo Abdullah v. Province of East Pakistan P L D 1960 S C 164 ref. Appellant in person. Syed M. Shahudul Hague for Respondents Nos. 1 and 2. Date of institution/bearing : 2nd May' 131st August, 1982.. JUDGMENT MUHAMMAD IRSHAD KHAN (MEMBER).-This is an appeal by Mrs. Musarrat Burkie, Director, Information Service Academy, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Islamabad, for expunction of adverse remarks recorded in her A. C. Rs. 2. We have heard the appellant and the learned counsel for the respondents Nos. l and 2, Mr. M. Shahudul Haque, and perused all the relevant records including the A. C. Rs. of the appellant pertaining to the periods 1964 to 1981, produced before us by the respondent-department. The case of the appellant as averred in the memo. of appeal and is the submissions made before us during the course of hearing, briefly speaking, is that presently the appellant is in Grade-19 and is serving as Direc­tor in the Information Service Academy, Islamabad. She has put in more than 38…

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492