| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1957 SLG 60 1957 SLD 60 1957 PLD 519 |
Lahore High Court
Criminal Appeal No. 831 of 1956, decided on 2nd April 1957, from the order of Malik Muhammad Aslam Khan, Sessions Judge, Dera Ghazi Khan, dated the 19th November 1956
ABDUL AZIZ KHAN AND ORTCHESON, JJ
Hamid-ud-Din-and Buland Iqbal Khan for Appellant. Abdul Qayyum Khan, for A. G. for
Respondent (State)
Criminal Appeal No. 831 of 1956, decided on 2nd April 1957, from the order of Malik Muhammad Aslam Khan, Sessions Judge, Dera Ghazi Khan, dated the 19th November 1956
ABDUL AZIZ KHAN AND ORTCHESON, JJ
Hamid-ud-Din-and Buland Iqbal Khan for Appellant. Abdul Qayyum Khan, for A. G. for
Respondent (State)
GHULAM HAIDER
VS
THE STATE
Law: Criminal Procedure Code (V of 1898)
Section: 161,162
Criminal Procedure Code (V of 1898)----- -----Ss. 161 & 162---Omission in statement under S. 161 cannot be used in favour of prosecution. Held, that while there is some conflict of judicial authority as to whether an omission in a statement under section 161, Criminal Procedure Code can be utilised, but on one point at least opinion is unanimous that only the accused can claim to use the previous statement of a prosecution witness for the purpose specified in the proviso to section 162, Criminal Procedure Code, and that the prosecution cannot use it against the accused either to corroborate a witness or to contradict him if he has been declared hostile and the Court cannot circumvent the provisions of section 162, Criminal Procedure Code, by a process of deduction. Nandlall Chakravarty v. King Emperor 49 C W N 434 ref. JUDGMENT ORTCHESON, J.-----Ghulam Haider, aged 29 years, has been convicted under section 302, P. P. C. by the learned Sessions Judge, .Dera Ghazi Khan, and sentenced to death for the murder of his sister Mst. Jindan, wife of Imam Bakhsh (P. W. 3). He has appealed and the case is also before us for confirmation of the death sentence under section 374, Criminal P. C. The appellant arid the deceased were residents of Chah Dosewala. According to the prosecution, the deceased's husband Imam Bakhsh suspected his wife of having illicit connection with one Ilahi Bakhsh alias Ilahu. Although, according to Imam Bakhsh, he did not communicate his suspicions to the appellant,' the latter some how learned of the liaison. At about midday on the 30th of September 1956, Sohanra (P. W. 9) was grazing his goats near Chah Dosewala when the appellant passed him, armed with the dang (Exh. P. 1), and went to the house of the deceased. Shortly afterwards Sohanra heard an alarm coming from the direction of the house and ran to the spot, where he found Mst. Jindan being beaten by the appellant. He called on him to stop but the appellant told him to mind his own business, and as the appellant's uncle Ramza had also arrived and was trying to rescue Mst. Jindan, Sohanra decided not to interfere, and went back to his flock. Not long afterwards the appellant came out of…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492