Case Details

Citation(s)
1957 SLG 46 1957 SLD 46 1957 PLD 400
Lahore High Court
Criminal Revision No. 486 of 1956, decision dated: 27th February 1957, case reported by Sessions Judge, Lyallpur Division at Lyallpur, under section 438, Criminal Procedure Code with his No. 189/RK of 1956
S. A. RAHMAN, C, J
Ismat Ullah Advocate for Petitioner. Sh. Maqbool Ahmad for (M. C. Gojra) for
Respondent (M. C. Gojra). S. M. Naseem for, A. G. West Pakistan for the State

ABDUR RASHID

VS

THE STATE--Respondent

Law: Punjab Municipal Act, 1911

Section: 4,197,199

Law: Punjab Municipal Act, 1911

Section: 4,197,199

Law: Punjab Agricultural Produce Markets Act, (V of 1939)

Section: 4,4(2)

(a) Punjab Municipal Act (III of 1911)------ ------ Ss. 4 & 197 -License for sale of fruit and vegetables within Municipal limits-Necessary even for sales within area notified as market area under S.4, Punjab Agricultural Produce Markets Act (V of 1939). Held, that the area, lying within limits of a Municipality, (section 4, Punjab Municipal Act), which area is notified under section 4 of the Punjab Agricultural Produce Markets Act (V of 1939) as a notified market area, and which is controlled by the Market Committee, is within the municipal limits and is subject to all the incidents of the Municipal Laws, Bye-Laws and Regulations. Therefore, notwithstanding that the petitioner was in possession of a license under section 4 (2), Punjab Agricul­tural Produce Markets Act (V of 1939), for the sale of fruit. and vegetables within the market area, failure to take out a license under section 197 of the Punjab Municipal Act (III of 1911) was a contravention of the bye-laws of the Municipal Committee, in respect of the necessity of a license for the sale of fruit and vegetables within the municipal limits, and was punishable by virtue of section 199 of the Munici­pal Act. The two Acts inter-se were not repugnant to each other and could stand together. The provisions of the Municipal Act have not been superseded by those of the Markets Act, The latter Act has merely imposed an additional obli­gation on persons wanting to sell fruits and vegetables in the area controlled by the Market Committee, to obtain a license from that committee, over and above the license required to be taken out under the bye-laws framed by the Municipal Committee. Firm Muhammad Sadiq and others v. Small Town Committee Ram Nagar, etc. R. S. A. No. 147 of 1953, decided on the 24th of July 1954 dissented from. (b) Interpretation of Statutes------ -----Courts must lean against an interpretation which involves implied repeal of an existing statute. Where there is no express provision of repeal and, there is no compelling reason to the contrary, the Courts must always lean against an interpretation which involves an implied repeal of an existing statute. Corporation of Madras v. Madras Electric…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492