| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1957 SLG 14 1957 SLD 14 1957 PLD 85 |
Lahore High Court
Second Appeal No. 253 of 1954, decided on 10th December 1956, from the decree of Ch. Fazl-i-Haq, District Judge, Sialkot, dated the 22nd April 1954, reversing that of David Fazl-ud-Din, Senior Civil Judge, Sialkot, dated the 18th November 1953
B. Z. KAIKAUS, J
Ghias Muhammad for Appellant. Sh. Abdul Haque for
Respondent
Second Appeal No. 253 of 1954, decided on 10th December 1956, from the decree of Ch. Fazl-i-Haq, District Judge, Sialkot, dated the 22nd April 1954, reversing that of David Fazl-ud-Din, Senior Civil Judge, Sialkot, dated the 18th November 1953
B. Z. KAIKAUS, J
Ghias Muhammad for Appellant. Sh. Abdul Haque for
Respondent
Master ALI MUHAMMAD
VS
THE FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN
Law: Estate Duty Act, 1950
Section: 7,10
Estate Duty Act (X of 1950) (as amended), S. 7 and S. 10, second proviso- Waqf-Gift to charity-Waqf alal-aulad Reservation of benefit to himself by waqif-Corpus of property not deemed to have "passed" but only the benefit so reserved--Such benefit, extending over whole of waqf property, cannot be exempted under S. 7 as remuneration of the office of Mutwalli. The second proviso to section 10, (which -deals with gifts) Estate Duty Act shows that waqf is regarded as only a gift-a gift to charity or technically to the Almighty. The proviso limits the application of the first paragraph of section 10 so as to exclude, in case of reservation of benefit by the waqif, the corpus of the waqf property from the operation of the Estate Duty Act and to include only the income of the property and that too at death of waqif. An authority to spend the whole income of waqf property for one's benefit is not by itself a provision for salary of a Mutawali and thus cannot escape duty under the Act. JUDGMENT KAIKAUS, J.----This appeal arises out of a suit relating to the liability of the estate of a deceased person to pay estate duty. One Haji Shahab-ud-Din, who was possessed of considerable property, executed a waqf deed in respect of the whole of his property on the 2nd of January 1931. The deed was of the kind that is called waqf alannafs wal-aulad, i.e., the waqif reserved to himself the income of the dedicated properties for his life, and, after his death the income was to be enjoyed by his descendants generation after generation. The ultimate benefit of course was to go to charity as is required by law for the creation of a valid waqf alai-aulad. Haji Shahab-ud-Din appointed himself the first Mutawali and made a declaration in the waqf deed that henceforward his possession was that of a Mutawalli. Later, on the 27th of April 1935, he executed another waqf deed of his property. The object of this deed was to exclude certain waqf property, which was included in the earlier waqf deed on the ground that it did not belong to him. The terms and conditions of waqf in this deed are the same as in the earlier deed, except that there is some amplification of those conditions. Haji…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492