| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1981 SLG 84 1981 SLD 84 1981 PTD 200 (1982) 45 TAX 5 |
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
E. D. A. No. 34 of 1978-79, decision dated: 28tb January,1979
MUHAMMAD MAZHAR ALI, A. A. ZUBERI AND ABRAR HUSSAIN NAQVI MEMBERS
Ahmad Shuja Khan for Appellant. Sikandar Kaleem for
Respondent
E. D. A. No. 34 of 1978-79, decision dated: 28tb January,1979
MUHAMMAD MAZHAR ALI, A. A. ZUBERI AND ABRAR HUSSAIN NAQVI MEMBERS
Ahmad Shuja Khan for Appellant. Sikandar Kaleem for
Respondent
Law: Estate Duty Act, 1950
Section: 38,39,42,4
(a) Estate duty--- ------Cash-in-hand---Assessment-Deceased withdrawing an amount of Rs. 500 from his Savings Bank Account a few days before his death Presumption that enough cash-in-hand was available-Held, unjust Addition knocked off. (b) Estate Duty Act (X of 1950)---Ss. 38, 39 & 42 read with S. 4-Hydrogenated Vegetable Oil Industry (Control and Development) Act (LXV of 1973), S. 5-Stock in shares- Valuation-Deceased owning shares in private limited Company- Such Company taken over by Federal Government in pursuance of Act of 1973-Value of shares of deceased in such Company passing on to accountable persons ascertainable with reference to value of total assets of Company-Second mode of valuation on basis of open market value cannot be adopted in such case-Ascertainment of assets of Company and value of shares-Not dependent on know ledge of ex-share holders-Controller of Estate Duty, in his wide discretion, can take into consideration all facts made available to him or any material relevant for valuation of assets-Question of published or unpublished information of balance-sheet-Held, irrelevant consideration--Valuation of shares of deceased by Controller on basis of documents including balance-sheet available to him and amount of compensation paid by Government to accountable persons about two months after deceased's death-Held: Cannot be brushed aside merely because certain balance-sheet had not been published or certain material not available at time of deceased's death was made use of Value of shares, in circumstances of case, to be made with reference to value of total assets of Company i.e. break up value-Held, further that market value of shares in question could not be taken as Nil [By majority] Per Muhammad Mazhar Ali and Abrar Hussain Naqvi, Members; A. A. Zuberi, Member (contra). 1974 P T D 119; (1978) 37 Taxation 41 (Trib.); (1977) 35 Taxation 14 (Trib.); (1966) 13 Taxation 26 (Trib.); (1898) I Q B 355; Salvesen's Trustees v. I. R. C. (1930) S I T 386; Inland Revenue, The Commissioners v. Crossman, (1937) A C 26; Finaly's Trustees v. Inland Revenue Commissioner (1938) 22 A T C 43; In re: Lynell (1970) 75 1 T R 564; In re: Holt (1953) 1 W L R…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492