Case Details

Citation(s)
1956 SLG 63 1956 SLD 63 1956 PLD 200
Lahore High Court
Review Petition No. 13 of 1955 decided on 3rd November, 1955 under O. XLVII, Rule 1 and section 151, C. P. C. for review of the order, dated the 28th June 1955, passed by Muhammad Yaqub Ali Khan, J. in Regular Second Appeal No. 241 of 1955
MUHAMMAD YAQUB ALI, JJ
Said Akbar for Petitioner. Muhammad Akram for
Respondent

ALLAH DAD

VS

MUHAMMAD AZEEM

Law: Provincial Small Cause Courts Act, 1887

Section: SchdII,8

Provincial Small Cause Courts Act (IX of 1887), Schd II, Art. 8-"House" includes shop. In Article 8 of Schedule II to the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act the word "house" has been used by Legislature in contradistinction to 'land'-and as such a suit for the recovery of shop rent is a suit cognizable by a Small Cause Court. Matwal Das v. Nand Lal A I R 1928 Lah. 284, Daniel v. Coulsting 14 L J C P 70, Mst. Ahmadi Begum v. Cirraj Kishore A I R 1927 All. 194, Nathu v. Sonasa A I R 1922 Nag. 15 and Nathu Ram v. Uttam Chand A I R 1939 Pesh. 14 ref. JUDGMENT MUHAMMAD YAQUB ALI, J.-The petitioner filed a suit for recovery of Rs.195 as arrears of rent of a shop situated in Gujrat. The suit was dismissed by the two Courts below and aggrieved by it he came up in second appeal before this Court, being R. S. A. No. 241 of 1951. This appeal was dismissed by me in limine on 28th of June 1955 on the ground that the suit being of a nature cognizable by a Small Cause Court, no second appeal was competent under section 102 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The plaintiff-appellant has applied for review of that order and I issued notice in this application on the contention of Raja Said Akbar, learned counsel for the petitioner, that a suit for recovery of rent of a shop was excluded from the jurisdiction of a Small Cause Court under Article 8 of the Second Schedule x to the Provincial Small Cause Courts Act. At the hearing of, this petition Mr. Muhammad Akram, learned counsel for the respondent, has cited a number of authorities, including Matwal Das v. Nand Lal (A I R 1928 Lah. 284) in which it has been held that the words "house rent" used in the aforementioned Article would cover and include shop rent. The leading authority on this point is Nga Kan v. Mimya (4 1 C 822) in which it was laid down that a stall in a market, which was sometimes used as a dwelling place, was also a house within the ambit of Article 8. In coming to this conclusion, the learned Judge referred to the dictionary meaning of the word "house" in Webster's, Wharton's Law Lexicon, Stroud's Law Lexicon and Tomlins's Law Dictionary. In Stroud's Law Lexicon, the word "house" is defined as "a structure of a…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492