Case Details

Citation(s)
1956 SLG 42 1956 SLD 42 1956 PLD 45
Lahore High Court
Civil Reference Case No. 3 of 1952. Reference answered on 4th April, 1955
M. R. KAYANI, A. C.J. AND AKHLAQUE HUSSAIN, J
Malik Muhammad Hussain for Petitioner (I. T. Commissioner Punjab and N.W.F.P.) M. Y. Ali Khan, Norman Edmunds, and R. Sidhwa, for
Respondent (Mrs. E. V. H. Miller

In the matter of the Income Tax Assessment of MRS. E. V. H. MILLER co The Colyana Estate, Okara, for the year 1949-50

Law: Income Tax Act, 1922

Section: 66(1),4(3)(viii),18(5),49B

Reference under section 66 (1) of the Income Tax Act (XI of 1922) as adapted by the Pakistan (Adaptation of Income Tag, Profits Tax and Revenue Recovery Acts). Order 1947, by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Pakistan, Lahore. (R. A. No. 24 of 1951-52, assessment year 1949-50). In the matter of the Income Tax Act (XI of 1922), as adapted by. the Pakistan (Adaptation of Income Tax, Profits Tax and Revenue Recovery Acts) Order 1947. (a) Income Tax Act (XI of 1922), S. 4 (3) (viii)-Divi­dends distributed by a Company to its shareholders out of "agri­cultural income" are "agricultural income" in the hands of shareholders-Income Tax Act (XI of 1922), Ss. 18 (5) and 49-B. Dividends distributed by a Company to its shareholders out of "agricultural income" is agricultural income in the hands of such shareholders within the meaning of the Income Tax Act. This answer to the Commissioner's Reference was supported by sections 18 (5) and 49-B of the Act which, respectively, state that payment of tax by the Company "shall be treated as payment of income-tax or super-tax on behalf of" the shareholder (section 18 (5)) and that the shareholder receiving dividend "shall be deemed in respect of such dividend himself to have paid income-tax" Per Akhlaque Hussain, J.-The definition of "dividend" in subsection (6-A) of section 2 clearly indicates that it is the profits of the Company which are distributed amongst its shareholders, that is to say, it is agricultural income itself which, in part or in whole, is distributed amongst its shareholders. Provisions in the Act entitling a shareholder benefit, or refund, of the income-tax paid by the Company also unmistakably point to the conclusion that the Act treats the income of a shareholder received by way of a dividend the same as the income of the Company. The dividend out of the agricultural income of a Company is agricultural income in the hands of a share­holder because the latter receives it in recognition of his right to it. The real test in all cases is whether the recipient has received the income of the Company in pursuance of a right to receive it as such. It is wholly immaterial for the purposes of the Act whether the…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492