Case Details

Citation(s)
1956 SLG 136 1956 SLD 136 1956 PLD 824
Lahore High Court
Petition under section 223-A of the Government of India Act, 1935, (Art. 170, Constitution of Pakistan.. dates of hearing: 16th and 17th April 1956
B. Z. KAIKAUS, AND AKHLAQUE HUSSAIN, JJ
Sh. Bashir Ahmad, S. M. Zafar and Amir Ahmad for Petitioner. S. A. Mahmood A.A.G. for
Respondent (1)

Syed HADI ALI

VS

THE GOVERNMENT OF WEST PAKISTAN and others

Law: Constitution of Pakistan, 1973

Section: 170

Law: Punjab Town Improvement Act, (IV of 1922)

Section: 10(d)

(a) Constitution of Pakistan, Art. 170-----Administrative order-Removal, by Provincial Government, of Trustee, of Lahore Improvement Trust under S. 10 (d), Punjab Town Improvement Act (IV of 1922)-Administrative Authority's duty to act justly, fairly and reasonably-Writ Jurisdiction of High Court-Case for direction under Art. 170-Notice to show cause-Necessity of, even where notice not prescribed by law. By a notification the Punjab Government, in exercise of their powers under section 10 (d) of the Punjab Town Im­provement Act (IV of 1922) removed the petitioner from membership of the Board of Trustees of the Lahore Improve­ment Trust on account of his having "flagrantly abused the powers of a Trustee", the allegation being that he had got his name put on a sub-committee which was to deal with an offer of purchase of shop-sites, made by the Trust to the Pakistan Cloth Market Federation, a body of which the petitioner was the President. No notice to show cause against his removal was given to the petitioner. In fact, such a notice was not prescribed by the Act. Held, that even in respect of purely administrative acts there is a duty to act justly, fairly, and reasonably, and if the order impugned be one which could not possibly have been passed by a person acting justly, fairly and reasonably, the order will be invalid in law. Moreover, although a show cause was not necessary in all cases where an executive order was passed, the duty to act justly, fairly and reasonably necessitat­ed in this case the grant of an opportunity of explanation to the petitioner by the Provincial Government before passing the order in dispute. Whether the duty to act justly, fairly and reason­ably will involve in a particular case the giving of notice would depend on the circumstances of that case. Held, that the High Court had jurisdiction to deal with a breach of such duty, under Art. 170 of the Constitution of Pakistan. Leslie Williams v. Haines Thomas Giddy 111 C 509, Halsbury Volume 31, page 533, Maxwell Ninth Edition, page 129, Cooper v. The Wandsworth Board of Works 143 Eng Rep. 414, Hopkins v. Smethwick Local Board of Health (1890) 24 Q B D 712, Ghisalal v. Regional Transport…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492