Law:

Section:

Civil service- --- Adverse remarks-Remarks for 3 consecutive years recorded by same Officer-Communicated jointly in one lot-Reports prior to 3 years recorded by same officer fairly good-Proposal of transfer by same Officer pressed during period of adverse remarks-Inference of ill-will could he drawn on part of reporting Officer in such circum­stances-Adverse remarks, in circumstances, expunged by Service Tribunal--Punjab Service Tribunals Act (IX of 1974), S. 4. JUDGMENT M. SALEEM CHAUDHRY (CHAIRMAN).--Mr. Mohammad Nasrullah Khan, appellant, is a Lecturer in Grade 18 with about 19 years service. Two batches of Lecturers were promoted as Assistant Professors from Grade 17 to Grade 18. According to the appellant, during 1977, a large number of lecturers junior to him were promoted to Grade 18. No reason was given for not promoting the appellant. An application was submitted on 25-8-77 by the appellant enquiring the reasons for his non-promotion. The appellant was ultimately informed by a letter dated 24-10-77 that he teas ignored due to the unsatisfactory record of service. The appellant submitted an applica­tion dated 18-12-1977 in which he represented that his record has been satisfactory throughout the service and as such the decision was not justified. It was at this stage that the Director of Education, Lahore, communicated vide letter dated 28-2-78 to the appellant adverse remarks from the ACRs. of the appellant for the years 1974, 1975 and 1976. The remarks are as under:-- 1974.--Inclined to be outspoken and arrogant at times. Could be a more desirable colleague if he learns to control his temper and subordinate his personal interests. 1975.-An average teacher interested only in his class. Slightly whimsical and eccentric. Inclined to be blunt and arrogant 'fried to create administrative problems. The Directorate was moved for his transfer as his presence considered detrimental to the College Administration. 1976.- An average teacher interested only in his class work. Slightly whimsical and eccentric. Inclined to be arrogant at times. Tried to create administrative problems. Appologised for his misbehaviour when his transfer case matured last year. Trying…

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492