| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1955 SLG 276 1955 SLD 276 (1955) 28 ITR 454 |
Bombay High Court
CHAGLA, C.J. AND TENDOLKAR, J.
Deprecated: str_replace(): Passing null to parameter #3 ($subject) of type array|string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 395
CHAGLA, C.J. AND TENDOLKAR, J.
Deprecated: str_replace(): Passing null to parameter #3 ($subject) of type array|string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 395
Jeshinghbhai Ujamshi
v.
Commissioner of Income Tax
Law:
Section:
JUDGMENT Chagla, CJ.-This reference arises on a misapprehension on the part of the Tribunal as to the law that we laid down in the case of Jeshinghbhai Ujamshi v. Commissioner of Income-tax [1950] 18 ITR 23 . We were considering the case of the same assessee and it appeared that the assessee had two firms one at Bhavnagar which he had started in 1918 and the other in Ahmedabad which he started in 1934, and the question that arose was whether when there are common partners in two firms they can in the eye of the income-tax law constitute two separate firms. The view taken by the Tribunal was that if the partners are common there can only be one firm, and in coming to that conclusion they applied the principle of ordinary civil law. We differed from that view and we pointed out that a firm was a taxable unit under the Income-tax Act, and for the purpose of the Income-tax Act a firm was an entity which it was not under the ordinary civil law, and therefore we sent back the case to the Tribunal in order to determine whether the two firms carried on the same business or separate businesses, and we emphasized the fact that the question whether the business was one or separate was a question of fact which could only be determined by the Tribunal after taking into consideration all the relevant materials. This matter having gone back to the Tribunal the Tribunal has considered all the materials and has come to the conclusion that the two firms at Bhavnagar and at Ahmedabad constitute only one business. Now, if this was a finding of fact arrived at pursuant to our directions, then the finding would be binding upon us, but the finding has been arrived at, not on the appreciation of evidence or on a consideration of materials placed before it but it has come to the conclusion, as already indicated, with respect to the Tribunal, on a complete misapprehension as to the law laid down in the decision just referred to. The view taken by the Tribunal is that no question of there being two businesses can arise if the…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492