| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1955 SLG 24 1955 SLD 24 1955 PLD 187 |
Lahore High Court
Second Appeal No. 244 of 1953 decided on 14th October, 1954, from the decree of the Court of Abdul Samad Khan, Additional District Judge, Multan, dated the 4th May 1953
B. Z. KAIKAUS, J
Mahmud Ali, for Appellants. Mohsin Shah, for
Respondents
Second Appeal No. 244 of 1953 decided on 14th October, 1954, from the decree of the Court of Abdul Samad Khan, Additional District Judge, Multan, dated the 4th May 1953
B. Z. KAIKAUS, J
Mahmud Ali, for Appellants. Mohsin Shah, for
Respondents
Mst. BHIRAWAN and 3 others
VS
AHMAD BAKHSH and others
Law: Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908)
Section: 100
Law: Evidence Act, (1 of 1872)
Section: 35
(a) Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908), S. 100-District sludge sole judge of facts including question of importance or otherwise of documents ;or reliability of witnesses-Conclusions from facts-May not be impeached unless not possible in law. The contention of appellants' counsel was that there were some documents which ought to have been regarded as important and which the District judge did not rely upon, while there were some documents on which the learned District judge relied and which had been prepared under circumstances throwing doubt on their correctness. Held : This is hardly the kind of attack which can sustain a second appeal. The District judge is the sole judge of facts and the conclusions from facts arrived at by him cannot be impeached unless the conclusions be not possible in law. An appellate Court is not debarred from setting aside a finding of fact simply because the finding is based on oral evidence or on the opinion of the learned trial judge as to the reliability of witnesses. (b) Evidence Act (I of 1872), S. 35-Copy of deaths record kept by District Health Officer-Relevant. Section 35 of the Evidence Act speaks of two kinds of documents, one those in which entries are made by any person in performance of a duty specially enjoined by the law of the country and the other a record kept by a public servant in the discharge of his official duty. Copy of an entry in record of deaths kept by a District Officer of Health, even if such record is itself a copy of the Register of Deaths kept at the Police Station, is relevant to prove the date of death of a person. If by statute there is a provision for the preparation of a particular document which is a copy of another public document, the copy prepared is also a public document falling within the purview of section 35 of the Evidence Act. It may be regarded as duplicate, but even if it is regarded as a copy, it does become a public record kept by a public servant in the discharge of his official duties. JUDGMENT KAIKAUS, J.---The property in dispute in this second appeal belonged to one Ata Bakhsh who died according to the plaintiffs on 20th of March, 1951, and according to the defendants about a…
Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492