| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1984 SLG 3733 = 1984 SLD 3733 = 1984 PLJ 230 |
Lahore High Court
Cr. Appl. No. 95 of 1981, decided on 14-9-1983
Presented By: MUHAMMAD ASLAM MIAN, J
Ch. Riyasat AH, Advocate for Appellant. Mr. Mohammad Arshad Khan, Advocate for State.  • Mr. Ehtesham Qadir Shah, Advocate for Complainant. Dates of hearing : 20-4-1983 &4/9/17/23/28-5-1983
Cr. Appl. No. 95 of 1981, decided on 14-9-1983
Presented By: MUHAMMAD ASLAM MIAN, J
Ch. Riyasat AH, Advocate for Appellant. Mr. Mohammad Arshad Khan, Advocate for State.  • Mr. Ehtesham Qadir Shah, Advocate for Complainant. Dates of hearing : 20-4-1983 &4/9/17/23/28-5-1983
SHER MUHAMMAD and Another—Appellants
VERSUS
THE STATE—Respondent
Law: Pakistan Penal Code (XLV of 1860)
Section: 302
Pakistan Penal Code (XLV of i860)— S. 302/201/34—Murder, offence of—Conviction for—Evidence,,appreciation of—Acquittal—Confessions made by appellants u/s-164 Cr.P.C. rejected and ruled out of consideration—Recoveries not believable—Deceased already challaned in various criminal cases in­cluding murder and abduction cases—Probability of deceased having: been killed by some body else, not excluded—Prosecution case as a whole lacking proper evidence—Conviction and sentences, set aside— Appellants acquitted. [P 237] E, F,G,H,J&K Pakistan Penal Code (XLV of I860)— -------- S. 302—Murder—Evidence, appreciation of—Deceased challaned' in number of criminal cases including murder and abduction cases— Probability of deceased having been killed by someone else, held,, not to be excluded. [P. 237] / (iii) Evidence Act (I of 1872)— -------- Ss. 24 to 30-—Confession—Evidentiary value of—Held: Confession^. as general rule of law to be receivable as testimony or as admission admissible against its maker. (P. 236 ]B (it) Evidence Act (I of 1872)— -------- Ss. 24 to 26—Confession when not admissible—Held : Confession, if coming within ingredients of Ss. 24, 25 or 26 of Evidence Act,, then* same to be neither relevant nor admissible. [P. 236] C (v) Confession— -Voluntary—Probative value—Conviction—Basis. for—Held : Con­ fession if proved as voluntarily made by person confessing conviction 10 follow immediately and courts not to be required to look for corroborative evidence anywhere though as abundant caution, Judges, have been looking for other facts so as to assure themselves that con­fessional statements happen to be voluntary [P. 235] A <»i) Confession— ------ Relevancy…