| Citation(s) |
|---|
| 1963 SLG 3361 = 1963 SLD 3361 = 1963 PLD 182 |
Sindh High Court
First Appeal No. 15 of 1960, decided on 24th September 1962.
Presented By: Qadeeruddin Ahmad, J (On difference of opinion between Wahiduddin Ahmad, and A. S. Faruqui, JJ)
Z. C. Valiani for Appellants. Tahir Hussain for
Respondent. S. Riazul Hassan for Asian Mutual Insurance Co. S. M. Sadi Amicus curiae. Dates of hearing (before D. B.) : 7th and 13th March 1962 ; (before Qadeeruddin Ahmad, J,) : 27th August and 12th September 1962
First Appeal No. 15 of 1960, decided on 24th September 1962.
Presented By: Qadeeruddin Ahmad, J (On difference of opinion between Wahiduddin Ahmad, and A. S. Faruqui, JJ)
Z. C. Valiani for Appellants. Tahir Hussain for
Respondent. S. Riazul Hassan for Asian Mutual Insurance Co. S. M. Sadi Amicus curiae. Dates of hearing (before D. B.) : 7th and 13th March 1962 ; (before Qadeeruddin Ahmad, J,) : 27th August and 12th September 1962
MESSRS RAH-E-MANZIL TRANSPORT AND Others-Appellant s
VERSUS
MUHAMMAD AMEEN--Respondent
Law: Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908)
Section: O. V111, r. 5
Civil Procedure Code (V of 1908), O. V111, r. 5-Allega tion of rash and negligent driving of vehicle not denied specifically-- Deemed to have been admitted. Tort-Vicarious liability-Manager looking after transport business on behalf of owner-Not liable in damages for death caused by rash or negligent act of servant of owner. Motor Vehicles Act (IV of 1939), S. 96 (2)-"Proceedings" means "suit"-Notice, to make insurer liable in damages, must be given in course of suit before judgment is delivered (Per Qadeeruddin Ahmad, J., agreeing with Faruqui, J., on difference of opinion between Wahiduddin Ahmad, J. and Faruqui, J.) (Per Wahiduddin, J. : Insurer liable even if notice is given during execution proceedings or appeal-"Proceedings" includes proceed ings in suit, appeal, or execution-General Clauses Act (X of 1897), S. 6 (e)-Sarupsingh Mangatsingh v. Nailkant Bhaskar A I R 1953 Bom. 109 ; Windsor v. Chalcraft (1939) 1 K B 279 ; Royal Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Abdul Muhammad Meheralli A I R 1955 Bom. 39 ; Vanguard Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sarla Devi and others A I R 1959 Pb. 297 ; British India General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Captain Itbar Singh and others A I R 1959 S C 1331 ; Halsbury's Laws of England (Ed. III), Vol. XXII, para. 696 ; Deb Narain Dutt v. Narendra Krishna & Co. I L R 16 Cal. 267 ; Sat Ghuri v. Mujidan I L R 15 Cal. 107 ; Mungal Pershad Dichit v. Grija Kant Lahiri I L R 8 Cal. 51 ; Ratanchand Shrichand v. Hanmantra V. Shivbakas 6 Bombay High Court Report 166 and Thakur Prasad v. Ahsan Ali I L R 1 All. 668 ref. [pp. 190, 198 207] C et seq, D et seq, E et seq. Words and Phrases-"Action"-Defined. Interpretation of Statutes-Construction to be adopted that will "suppress the mischief and advance the remedy"-Object of statute : public safety ; wording to be interpreted widely to effect such object. Interpretation of Statutes-Three methods : Analytical,…