Case Details

Citation(s)
1955 SLG 140 1955 SLD 140 1955 PLD 430
Lahore High Court
Criminal Appeal No. 513 of 1953 decided on 11th February 1955
S. A. RAHMAN, C.J. AND SHABIR AHMAD, J
S. A. Mahmud, Assistant Advocate-General for Appellant. Kh. Abdur Rahim, for
Respondent (1);
Respondent (2) in person

THE CROWN

VS

NASEER AHMAD and another

Law: Punjab Foodgrains (Export Control) Order, 1952

Section: 2(c)

Law: Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act, 1946

Section: 8

Attempt to commit an offence-Act constituting attempt need not be criminal by itself-Attempt to export 35 bags of wheat bran from Rawalpindi to Kohat in violation of Punjab Foodgrains (Export Control) Order, 1952, paragraph 2 (c)-Whether complete when intention to export was proved though motor truck had only covered 20 miles out of a distance of 110 miles between the two places---Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act (XXIV of 1946), S. 8. It is not necessary that before an act can be considered to be an attempt to commit a crime it must itself be criminal. The respondents with the truck carrying 35 bags of wheat bran left Rawalpindi for Kohat which places are separated by about 110 miles from each other and had gone about 20 miles when the truck was stopped by the police and checked. There was an entry in the log-book of the truck in the hand of the driver (one of the respondents) that the bags were meant to be taken to Kohat outside the Province of the Punjab. Held, that the respondents were guilty of an attempt to export wheat bran out of the Punjab under section 8 Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act (XXIV of 1946), section 8 read with paragraph 2 (c) of Punjab Foodgrains (Export Control) Order, 1952. If evidence on the record, be it direct or circumstantial or a combination of both, proves that the respondents would have crossed the border with the wheat bran had they not been stopped, the fact that they were stopped when they were at a considerable distance from the border cannot by itself prevent their act from amounting to an attempt to export the wheat bran they carried in the truck in which they were travelling. Crown v. Muhammad Raftque Safdar and others P L D 1952 Sind 28 dissented from. I L R 15 All. 173 and Stephen's Digest of Criminal Law, Art. 50 ref. JUDGMENT SHABIR AHMAD, J.---Naseer Ahmad a shopkeeper of Kohat, and Iqbal Shah, a motor driver of that place, were tried under section 8 of the Essential Supplies (Temporary Powers) Act XXIV of 1946 read with. paragraph 2 (c) of the Punjab Foodgrains (Export Control) Order, 1952 for having attempted to export 35 bags of wheat bran out of the Punjab to Kohat, with the result that each of…
🔒
Continue readingLogin or create an account to access the complete content.Login / Register

Deprecated: trim(): Passing null to parameter #1 ($string) of type string is deprecated in /home/digixyei/sldsystempk.com/view/master-layout/view_case.php on line 492